In a case that shook the Christian community in Cross River State, a self-proclaimed cleric and church founder, Apostle Favour Mexy Okoise has been convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment on multiple counts of rape and false pretences by a High Court in Calabar.
The church founder, an indigene of Esan West, Edo State, who formerly ran a fellowship before converting it into a full-fledged church, The Refiner’s Fire Church, was found guilty in two separate cases—HC-12C/2024 and HC-FC-5C/2024—on June 16 and 17, respectively.
The first case involved three counts of rape of three different ladies and one count of obtaining by false pretences, while the second centred on the rape of a 16-year-old minor.
Reports said that the court proceedings began in 2023.
The case was reportedly initiated by the Department of Public Prosecution (DPP), under the leadership of Okoi E. Ukam, Esq., and prosecuted by Cletus Adama, Esq., both of the Cross River State Ministry of Justice.
Legal practitioner Doris Nduanusi, Esq., who watched brief on behalf of the victims, disclosed that Okoise manipulated young female members of the church by coercing them into sexual acts under the guise of spiritual initiation.
“He told them it was a rite of passage to be used by God and referred to it as a ‘special dealing’ with the Holy Spirit,” she said.
Although the Ministry of Justice led the prosecution, significant support came from the Gender and Development Action (GADA), a civil society group led by Ambassador Nkoyo Toyo.
“It was a collaborative effort that ensured the voices of the victims were heard,” Nduanusi stated.
Despite his conviction, church members were reportedly told that the church founder was “on the mountain interceding for their destinies” since his remand in February 2024.
“It was only after the judgement that some began to realise they had been deceived for over a year,” Nduanusi added.
The convicted pastor remained unrepentant throughout the trial, a fact noted by the presiding judge in her ruling.
“He showed no remorse for his actions,” the court observed.
Concerns have now shifted to the operational structure of the church, which allegedly continues to function under a new location in the Nassarawa axis of the city, despite the conviction.
“The government must take urgent steps to dismantle the entire structure that enabled such abuse,” Nduanusi said, citing the risk of continued psychological and physical harm to congregants or parishioners.
“There are reports that prominent local pastors maintained affiliations with the church even after being made aware of the allegations.
As of press time, it remained unclear whether The Refiner’s Fire Church is officially registered with the Pentecostal Fellowship of Nigeria (PFN). However, ties reportedly exist between the church and senior PFN officials.
The Cross River State Ministry of Justice continues to demonstrate its unwavering commitment to justice and the rule of law.
In the first and second quarters of 2025 alone, the Ministry had secured convictions in multiple serious cases, including attempted murder, armed robbery, kidnapping, rape, and arson.
The Conclave with reports from Tribune
The sentencing of the self-proclaimed cleric for rape is a significant step towards justice for the victims. What do you think can be done to prevent such abuses of power and trust in religious settings?