Home Blog Page 4

Patience Jonathan on Her PhD Journey: My age and repeated assignments nearly discouraged me but ‘if Patience can do it, you too can do it’

Former Nigeria’s First Lady, Mrs Patience Jonathan, popularly known as ‘Mama P’, on Sunday shared her inspiring testimony of how she nearly gave up on her pursuit of a PhD due to self-doubt and the challenges she faced while working on her thesis.

Mrs. Jonathan recently obtained a PhD in Psychology, Guidance and Counselling from Ignatius Ajuru University of Education in Port Harcourt, Rivers State.

She was part of the institution’s 43rd Postgraduate Convocation Ceremony.

The former First Lady, who spoke during a testimony time on at Streams of Joy International Church, Abuja, led by Pastor Jerry Eze, recalled her difficult academic journey, marked by moments of frustration and self-doubt.

Jonathan admitted that the demands of academic life, particularly the repeated assignments and high expectations from lecturers, nearly pushed her to the brink.

Reflecting on her experience, she said in her characteristic voice, as the congregation cheered and laughed, “At times, my lecturer would get me angry and say, ‘Go and repeat this page.’

“Shey this man don’t know that I’m old.

“Very soon, I will leave this place and rest because what will I do with it? It’s just to keep the brain moving.

“But to God be the glory. That thing that seemed impossible, God made it possible, and I graduated.”

Despite her prominent background and previous public service, Jonathan said it was not a path she envisioned for herself after serving in high political office.

“When I went to pick up my PhD form, I thought I would not make it.

“I said, I have finished my career. I have served as First Lady of Nigeria. What am I going to do with a PhD?

“But God told me to go there. He said, ‘If your children can make it, why can’t you?’”

Jonathan also spoke about how she was humbled by the effort it took to sit in classrooms with much younger students.

“I would go to class and sit on the bench with my children.

“I was the ‘Mama’ among them, and I wasn’t ashamed.

“The teacher would be teaching, I would raise my hand and ask questions because the younger ones would understand immediately, but, as a ‘Mama’, I had to ask questions three times before I understood one thing,” she said.

Jonathan described the three-year programme as feeling like “40 years,” and attributed her perseverance to divine support.

The former First Lady urged that her testimony serve as a powerful encouragement to others, especially women and youths, so they do not see age or circumstance as a barrier to education.

“There is no age limit in education. If you are a hundred years old, you can make it.

“If you are ten years old, you can make it. Just be determined, and you will get there,” Jonathan said.

Watch the video below.

“𝗧ears 𝗠ay 𝗙low, 𝗕ut 𝗢ur 𝗣rayers 𝗥ise”: 𝗧he 𝗟aw 𝗖entre mourns with 𝗝. 𝗦. 𝗢kutepa, 𝗦𝗔𝗡, over the painful passing of his beloved daughter, 𝗗r. 𝗢jochide 𝗢kutepa

PRESS RELEASE

  1. The Administrators and Members of The Law Centre (TLC) have received with deep sorrow and heavy hearts the devastating news of the untimely and painful demise of Dr. Ojochide Okutepa, beloved daughter of our dear brother, friend, and co-Administrator, Jibril S. Okutepa, SAN.
  2. A brilliant medical doctor and a shining light, Dr. Ojochide’s sudden departure is not only a monumental personal loss to the Okutepa family, but also a communal tragedy felt across our platform and by all who value life, justice, and service to humanity. The loss of a child, especially one so full of promise, is a pain too deep for words, and one that echoes in eternity.
  3. Mr. Okutepa, SAN, himself expressed this unspeakable grief in his touching tribute: “It is difficult to comprehend your sudden departure, my beloved daughter. In all, I give glory to God… Sleep well, Ojochide. It is well. It is well. It is well.”
  4. Indeed, we share in his grief. We stand in solidarity with our brother, distinguished Senior Advocate of Nigeria, tireless advocate for justice, human rights defender, and a moral voice in our nation. At this moment of overwhelming loss, we pray that God, the Father of Compassion, will surround the entire Okutepa family with divine comfort and strength. In Matthew 5:4, the Bible tells us: “Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted.” In Psalm 34:18, it’s written: “The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit.”
  5. May the soul of Dr. Ojochide Okutepa rest in perfect peace. May her legacy live on in the lives she touched and the memories she leaves behind. And may God, in His infinite mercy, grant her family, friends, and all who mourn her the fortitude to bear this irreparable loss.
  6. We, the undersigned, write this on behalf of the entire TLC platform to offer our heartfelt condolences and unwavering support to Mr. Okutepa, SAN, his family, and all their loved ones.

Signed:

  1. AGE Boms Worgu;
  2. Amb. (AGE) Garba Gajam;
  3. Major Ben Aburime;
  4. Otunba Olusegun Otayemi;
  5. Emeka Ibe;
  6. Sylvester Udemezue;
  7. Sunny Odey;
  8. Hajia Altine Ibrahim;
  9. Olumide Babalola;
  10. Chief Nelson Imoh;
  11. Mrs Abiye Tam-George;
  12. Emmanuel Cosmas;
  13. Ike Augustine.
  14. Miss Bisola Onowe
    (Administrators of The Law Centre (TLC))
    Tel: 08109024556.
    Email: [email protected].
    (09 June 2025)

𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗟𝗔𝗪 𝗖𝗘𝗡𝗧𝗥𝗘 (𝗧𝗟𝗖)(An Advocacy Platform for Law, Legal Reforms, Justice Administration, Ethics, Good Governance, and Constitutional Democracy in Nigeria and Beyond)

Part 3 – Why Nigeria Needs to Create Special States for Fulani Herdsmen: Doing things differently to achieve different, better results (my second response to readers)

By Sylvester Udemezue

MEMORY VERSE:

(1). “We cannot solve our problems with the same level of thinking that created them.”
~ Albert Einstein

(2). “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” ~ often attributed to Einstein, Franklin, Twain, or Rita Mae Brown

THE MISCONCEPTION:

Please graciously read my open letter to Nigeria’s National Assembly, titled, “An Open Letter of National Emergency: A Call For Creation of Special States For Fulani Herdsmen” By Sylvester Udemezue, published on 02 June 2025. A common response to my proposal therein, is that Fulani already govern many states in Northern Nigeria. One reader remarked, “Fulanis (not even the ethnic ones) are Governors in all the Northern States except Taraba, Kogi, Benue, Plateau and Kwara.”

MY HUMBLE RESPONSE:

  1. Respectfully, the reaction quoted above (as given by a reader) misunderstands the very essence of my argument. With due respect, the presence of a Fulani governor in a state does not make that state a Fulani state. This distinction between political leadership and ethnic identity is fundamental. A state’s identity is not determined by the ethnicity of its governor, just as appointing a non-Igbo as Governor of Anambra would not erase its Igbo identity. Col. Rufai Garba (a northern Muslim) governed Anambra State during the Abacha era (1996–1998); Anambra didn’t become a northern or Fulani state. Ibok Abas, from Akwa Ibom, was Military Administrator of Rivers State. Yet Rivers retained its distinct Ijaw and Ikwerre character. Even as I write, Ibok Abas is the Sole Administrator of Rivers State, appointed for an initial period of six months by President Tinubu following declaration of a State of Emergency in the State. In AG Federation v. Abubakar (2007) 10 NWLR (Pt. 1041) 1, Niki Tobi, JSC said, “In our federating units, identity is largely a matter of historical and ethnic continuity, not mere legal appointments or administrative control.” The states currently governed by Fulani leaders remain, demographically and historically, the ancestral lands of their indigenous non-Fulani populations.
  2. The proposal to create special states or territories for Fulani nomads is not only pragmatic but entirely constitutional. The Nigerian Constitution in Section 8(1) empowers creation of states where specific political and procedural thresholds are met, including local government resolutions, referenda, and legislative approval. Section 14(2)(b) provides: “The security and welfare of the people shall be the primary purpose of government.” The perpetual conflict, displacement, and insecurity facing Fulani pastoralists are constitutional red flags warranting urgent and tailored governmental intervention. Section 17(3)(a): “The State shall direct its policy towards ensuring that all citizens have the opportunity for securing adequate means of livelihood.”
  3. Pastoralism, which is the traditional livelihood of Fulani herders, must be protected and supported by law and policy. The Land Use Act, 1978 in Section 1, provides, “All lands in the territory of each State in the Federation are vested in the Governor.” This Act entrenches sedentary landholding systems, marginalizing nomadic communities whose way of life does not align with state-based land control. It fuels displacement and conflict. Hence my proposal as the last resort in efforts towards achieving peace and improving security.
  4. There are some case law authorities endorsing federal flexibility and plural solutions to prevailing challenges. Nigeria’s jurisprudence supports tailored federal solutions for local, ethnic, and livelihood-based challenges. In AG Bendel v. AG Federation (1982) 3 NCLR 1, the Supreme Court underscored federalism’s need for adaptability to regional needs. Creating Fulani states aligns with this doctrine of adaptive federalism. In AG Lagos State v. AG Federation (2003) 12 NWLR (Pt. 833) 1. The Court emphasized decentralization as a key feature of Nigerian federalism. A uniform national policy (e.g., open grazing bans) without alternatives violates this federal principle.
  5. Persistent failures of current remedies demand radical rethinking. Despite several efforts, herder-farmer clashes continue. The following have been tried without success: (a). Open Grazing Bans: These criminalize Fulani lifestyles without viable alternatives, leading to escalation of resentment and lawlessness. (b). National Livestock Transformation Plan (NLTP, 2019): A noble idea, yet poorly implemented, inconsistently funded, and lacking community buy-in or legal backing. The problem is, Fulani herders are functionally stateless, lacking a homeland where their culture and livelihood are recognized and protected. Hence, a viable solution is to create special states (or constitutionally protected territories) dedicated to: (1). Fulani cultural autonomy, (2). Legal and secure pastoralism, (3). Community policing and conflict resolution, and (4). Integrated into Nigeria’s constitutional order
  6. Philosophical and Practical Justifications For the Proposal to Create Special States: Peter Drucker said, “If you want something new, you have to stop doing something old.” Barack Obama said, “Change will not come if we wait for some other person or some other time.” Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said, “We are confronted with the fierce urgency of now.” My proposal is not about ethnic favoritism but REALISM and conflict resolution. Nigeria’s history shows that peace is sustained where people have a sense of belonging, identity, and security. Without these, alienation breeds extremism.
  7. Comparative Global Illustrations Supporting The Proposal For Special States: Several countries have implemented similar models: (1). Ethiopia’s Federal States are defined along ethnic lines to protect minority identities and prevent inter-ethnic conflict. (2). India’s Nagaland and Mizoram were created for specific tribal groups to preserve culture and avoid national fragmentation. (3). South Sudan broke away from Sudan due to ethnic marginalization, after failed attempts at accommodation. Nigeria must act before a preventable crisis spirals into irreversible disintegration.
  8. Creating the special states is a constitutional and moral Imperative. There’s a legal maxim, that “The law must not only follow logic but must also respond to reality.” The consistent bloodshed from the herder-farmer conflict is a national emergency. The creation of Fulani states or constitutionally protected territories is not a luxury; it is a practical, peaceful, and constitutional necessity. This approach will: (a) De-escalate ethnic tensions; (b). Promote federal equity; (c). Protect a legitimate and lawful livelihood; (d). Foster long-term national unity. “The REALITY is: if we want different results, we must do things differently.” Let us stop patching up a bleeding wound with outdated bandages. Let us treat the cause, not just the symptoms, of national instability. Creating special Fulani states is not ethnic indulgence; it is strategic inclusion. May God give our leaders practical wisdom to do what is the best for our country under the prevailing circumstances.
    Long live the Federal Republic of Nigeria.
    Long live Peace, Unity, and Justice.
    Respectfully,
    Sylvester Udemezue (udems),
    Proctor, The Reality Ministry of Truth, Law and Justice (TRM) [A nongovernmental, nonaligned, nonprofit public-interest law advocacy group]
    Tel: 08021365545, 08109024556.
    Email: [email protected].
    (09 June 2025)

The views expressed by contributors are strictly personal and not of Law & Society Magazine.

Author of ‘The Day Of The Jackal’ Frederick Forsyth dies at 86

Best-selling author Frederick Forsyth, known for thriller novels including The Day Of The Jackal, has died at the age of 86, his agent has said.

“We mourn the passing of one of the world’s greatest thriller writers,” Jonathan Lloyd said in a statement.

Forsyth published more than 25 books, including The Odessa File and The Dogs of War, and sold 75 million books around the world, he said.

His publisher, Bill Scott-Kerr, said: “Still read by millions across the world, Freddie’s thrillers define the genre and are still the benchmark to which contemporary writers aspire. He leaves behind a peerless legacy which will continue to excite and entertain for years to come.”

Read Also: Obituary: Life as a thriller writer, fighter pilot, journalist and spy

Born in Kent in 1938, Forsyth joined the RAF at the age of 18 before becoming a war correspondent for the BBC and Reuters. He revealed in 2015 that he also worked for the British intelligence agency MI6 for more than 20 years.

Many of his fictional plots drew on his real-life experiences around the world.

He made his name with his first novel, 1971’s The Day Of The Jackal, which he wrote when he was out of work.

“[I was] skint, in debt, no flat, no car, no nothing and I just thought, ‘How do I get myself out of this hole?’ And I came up with probably the zaniest solution – write a novel,” he said.

It is a gripping tale, set in 1963, about an Englishman hired to assassinate the French president at the time, Charles de Gaulle.

The Day Of The Jackal was turned into a 1973 film starring Edward Fox as the Jackal, and then became a TV drama starring Eddie Redmayne last year.

PA Media Frederick Forsyth in 1984

Forsyth died on Monday after a brief illness, a statement said.

“We mourn the passing of one of the world’s greatest thriller writers,” Mr Lloyd said.

“Only a few weeks ago I sat with him as we watched a new and moving documentary of his life – In My Own Words, to be released later this year on BBC One – and was reminded of an extraordinary life, well lived.

“After serving as one of the youngest ever RAF pilots, he turned to journalism, using his gift for languages in German, French and Russian to become a foreign correspondent in Biafra.

“Appalled at what he saw and using his experience during a stint as a Secret Service agent, he wrote his first and perhaps most famous novel, The Day Of The Jackal, and instantly became a global bestselling author.”

PA Media Frederick Forsyth and Michael Caine drinking together in 1986
Michael Caine persuaded Forsyth to allow a film version of 1984 novel The Fourth Protocol

Mr Scott-Kerr said working with Forsyth had been “one of the great pleasures of my professional life”.

“The flow of brilliant plots and ideas aside, he was the most professional writer an editor could hope for,” he said.

“His journalistic background brought a rigour and a metronomic efficiency to his working practice, and his nose for and understanding of a great story kept his novels both thrillingly contemporary and fresh. It was a joy and an education to watch him at work.”

Forsyth followed The Day Of The Jackal with The Odessa File in 1972, which was adapted for the big screen in a film starring Jon Voight two years later.

The author had written a follow-up, Revenge of Odessa, with fellow thriller writer Tony Kent, which will be published this August.

His other best-selling works included 1984’s The Fourth Protocol, which became a film starring Michael Caine and Pierce Brosnan.

He was made a CBE for services to literature in 1997.

He had two sons with his first wife, Carole Cunningham. His second wife, Sandy Molloy died last October.

BBC

Alleged Looting by NAFDAC Officials: Anambra Woman files action, claims N110 million damages against NAFDAC

A businesswoman in Anambra state has instituted an action against the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control NAFDAC), alleging its operatives broke into her shop and looted goods that had nothing to do with food or drugs.

A businesswoman based in Onitsha, Anambra State, Eberechukwu Sophia Okoye, has dragged the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC) to a Federal High Court in Awka over alleged invasion of her office and seizure and looting of goods estimated at N15.746 million.

Among the items seized by NAFDAC were dozens of Jeans imported from Turkey, boxers, joggers, caps, condom packets, underpants, and Italian Palm Sandals.

Sources said that the present suit has unsettled the top hierarchy of NAFDAC, while fear is said to have gripped its staff members in Abuja, Lagos and the South East.

Joined as respondent in the suit marked: FHC/AWK/CS /162/2025 is the Director-General of NAFDAC, Prof Mojisola Adeyeye.

The plaintiff in the suit filed by her lawyer, Ifeanyi Ejiofor, is claiming N100 million as general and exemplary damages and N10 million, being the cost of the action.

The plaintiff wants the court to declare that the defendants, in the administration, management and control of food and drugs, broke into her shop, looted and carted away items not affiliated with drugs, food or chemicals.

Okoye also wants the court to declare that the seizure of her goods and looting of her shop is not only oppressive, unreasonable but also illegal.

She also wants the court to grant an order of perpetual injunction restraining the defendants, their servants, agents, or privies from taking further steps to break, lock up and tamper with her shop.

The case has been assigned to Court 2 at the Federal High Court in Awka, Anambra State.

Arise News had reported that on March 15, 2025, NAFDAC officials stationed to oversee the Ogbo-Ogwu Bridge Head Market, Onitsha, allegedly looted the shop of Ms. Sophia Eberechukwu Okoye, making away with non-pharmaceutical goods valued at N15.746 million.

Ejiofor had earlier demanded a thorough investigation and accountability, and a pre-action notice formally served on NAFDAC.

According to him, the arbitrary looting of a citizen’s business under the pretext of regulatory enforcement is “an egregious abuse of power, a criminal act, and a violation of fundamental rights.”

He had said, “While regulatory agencies have a duty to enforce compliance, such actions must strictly adhere to due process, fairness, and the rule of law. No government agency should be permitted to weaponise enforcement to inflict unwarranted hardship on innocent individuals.

“We remain unwavering in our pursuit of justice for Ms. Eberechukwu. Those responsible for this unlawful and reprehensible act must face the full weight of the law. Justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done.”

Six-year-old girl, 15 others arrested in Myanmar over retired-general’s death

16 persons, including a six-year-old girl, have been arrested in Myanmar over the assassination of a retired general.

Local media said he was shot dead in Yangon last month.

A former ambassador to Cambodia, Cho Tun Aung, was gunned down outside his home on May 22 in an attack claimed by an anti-junta group calling itself the “Golden Valley Warriors”.

Myanmar’s military seized power in a 2021 coup, plunging the country into a complex, multi-sided civil war involving pro-democracy guerrillas and resurgent ethnic minority armed groups.

Most fighting is confined to the countryside and smaller towns but grenade and gun attacks on junta-linked targets are regularly reported in Yangon, Myanmar’s largest city and commercial hub.

The Global New Light of Myanmar newspaper said 16 members of the Golden Valley Warriors — 13 men and three females — had been arrested in various locations.

Those held include the wife and six-year-old daughter of the suspected shooter, identified as Myo Ko Ko, the state-run newspaper said, without explaining what the girl is accused of.

The report said Myo Ko Ko and another suspect rode to the general’s home on bicycles and shot him before fleeing to a safe house.

The junta has suffered significant territorial setbacks in recent months but analysts say it is far from defeat, with a powerful air force supplied with Russian jets and military backing from China.

Valedictory speech by Hon. Justice M. L. Uwais, GCON, retired Chief Justice of Nigeria, delivered on Monday, 12th June 2006 at the Supreme Court of Nigeria, Abuja

On the 24th December, 1942, my father, Malam Abdullahi Uwaisu, died. I was six years old. He was an employee of the Nigerian Railway Department, as the Nigerian Railway Corporation was then known. It fell on my late mother, Hajia Hajara to bring me up singlehandedly together with my sister Hajiya Asamau and half-brother Alhaji Shehu Abubakar.

As God would have it, my mother remarried two years later to a school Headmaster, Malam Muhammadu Jumare. He it was that suggested that I should enrol in the Native Authority Elementary School, Kaduna, where he was teaching. My mother agreed and so I started my education there. However, after the first year at the school, my step-father was transferred in 1946 to Tudun Wada Elementary School Zaria.

I too had to transfer to the school. But as there were only two classrooms in the School, there were by that year only classes 1 and 3, I therefore could not join class 3 since I did not pass through class 2. For that reason I had to repeat class 1. I shared this school, amongst others, with Alhaji Rilwan Lukman, former Adviser to the President on Petroleum and Energy who was in class 3.

In 1950, I got admitted into Zaria Middle School where I had 2 years stint before I got admitted into Barewa College, Zaria. This was an elitist School. While educations in the two previous schools were free, fees were paid at Barewa College. In those days it was 12 Nigerian Pounds per annum. My Mother who by this time had got separated from my step father would have to struggle through trading to meet the responsibility. This she did with little or no help from anyone except the monthly rent that she collected from the house my late father left for us.

In 1956, the Northern Nigeria Government headed by the late Sir Ahmadu Bello, the Sardauna of Sokoto, took a decision to grant to all the students in Barewa College scholarship, thus making education in the school free like in the Elementary and the Middle School. Not only that, it was decided to return to the students’ parent all the fees paid from 1952 to 1956. The sum of 48 pounds was refunded to my mother who asked me to mention what I would like her to buy for me from the amount as a present. I chose a bicycle whose price was 8 pounds then. It was “Robin Hood’ brand. By this act, I became the first student in my class to possess a bicycle. This was a source of pride for me.

From Form 3 in Barewa College, I was able to obtain holiday jobs during the school’s vacation periods, the longest being 3 months to enable the expatriate teachers return to United Kingdom during summer for their leave. I secured temporary jobs at various times with Paterson Zochonis Ltd (PZ), the Veterinary Department of Zaria Native Authority and the United African Company Lid. (UAC). The salaries I earned from the jobs made me one of the richest amongst the students in my class. However this did not spoil me because my beloved mother kept on warning me to remember that I was an orphan and that I must behave myself and study hard. She was a stern disciplinarian who would not spare the rod.
While at Barewa College, before I completed my education, I developed interest in studying law. This came about by chance. I got encouragement from the legal practitioners then practicing in Zaria without their intending or knowing it.

These were the late Mr. Noel Grey,Kenneth Grey, who lives and practices in Kano, the late Hon. Justice Beckley of Lagos State High Court, the late Mr. Sawyer, from Lokoja and lately Alhaji A.G.F Razak, SAN. So on completing Form 6, in 1957, I applied for a Northern Nigeria Government scholarship to study law in the United Kingdom. I was invited in 1958 by the Northern Nigeria Scholarship Board for interview but somehow the telegram containing the invitation got to me late and so I missed the interview for that year. This was what made me to resign my appointments as Accounts Clerk with the Nigerian Tobacco Company Ltd. in Zaria early in 1959 to take up a civil service appointment as Publicity Assistant, in the Ministry of Information in Kaduna, in order to ensure that I did not miss the next interview in 1959 for which I applied.

After the interview took place, I was successful but there was still one hurdle to jump. There were other successful candidates. The government practice then was that the Ministry of Finance would have to approve the number of students who succeeded at the interview that would be granted scholarship particularly to travel abroad for studies.
Again, luck was against me and I was dropped. This was an inside information that was divulged to me by a relation that was a confidential secretary in the Ministry at the material time. I resigned to my fate. However, as luck would have it, soon after, the Government of Northern Nigeria decided about the same time in 1959 to have a crash-programme for training matured students to become lawyers for the purpose of being employed as the Magistrates and State Counsel in addition to training younger people on scholarship as lawyers.

The training was to take place initially at the Institute of Administration Zaria which later became a part of the Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria. Under a special arrangement with the Inns of Court in London, the students were to take Part I of the Bar Examination at the Institute and if successful to proceed to London to complete the course by taking Part II of the Examinations. The 1959 Programme was advertised in the newspapers and I applied as a civil servant. I was not even invited for the interview.

Amongst those successful were Hon. Justice Saidu Kawu and Hon. Justice A.B Wali who both became Justices of the Supreme Court. In the meanwhile, I was transferred to Kano where I worked with late Alhaji Muhammadu Dungus, who was a Senior Information Officer. When the second advertisement for the training in 1960 was advertised I was reluctant to apply. It was him that encouraged me to do so. By that time I had got married to my first wife Saratu in January,1960. As luck would have it, I was this time around called for the interview and later selected for the training. I received a telegram to that effect. My happiness was without limit, I so valued that telegram that I am still in possession and keeping custody of it. Twelve of us were admitted to the course in July 1960.

Those who succeeded too have been called to the English Bar with me are Hon. Justice M. M. A. Akanbi, CFR who was President of the Court of Appeal and the immediate past Chairman of the Independent Corrupt Practices and Related Oftences Commission (ICPC), late Hon. Justice Shebu Usman Mohammed, who was Chief Judge of Kaduna State and later Justice of the Supreme Court of Nigeria for a short period before his death in February 1993, late Hon. Justice Umaru Maidama, who was a Justice of the Court of Appeal, late Hon. Justice Anthony Aina Ekundayo, who was a Judge of the High Court of Kwara State, and late Hon. Justice Adamu Minijibir of the High Court of Kano State. Of the class of 12 nine of us got to England and only six of us got to be called to the English and Nigerian Bar. And of the same number (12), only Hon. Justice Akanbi and myself today remain alive. I am the last to relinquish public service by retiring today. Alhamdu Lillahi (Thanks be to Allah).

On completing my training and called to Bar, I was transferred from the Ministry of information of the Northem Nigeria to the Ministry of Justice as a Pupil State Counsel. I rose through the ranks to become Solicitor General and Permanent Secretary. I served in the State Counsel Chambers in Jos and the Headquarters in Kaduna. I travelled extensively to prosecute criminal and defend civil cases in Jos, Bauchi, Yola, Mubi, Maiduguri, Makurdi, Lokoja, Ilorin, Minna, Zaria which are provincial Headquarters then.

I served under the late Hon. Justice Mohammed Bello, GCON, my immediate predecessor-in-office as Chiel Justice of Nigeria, when he was the Director of Public Prosecutions (D.P.P) of Northem Nigeria. After the coup d’état of 1966, he was succeeded as D.P.P by Hon. Justice Mamman Nasir, GCON, former President of the Cour of Appeal. That was what brought us together up to 1968, when the civil servants of former Northern Nigeria were deployed to the 12 States created by General Yakubu Gowon. I found myself, together with Hon. Justice Nasir and Hon. Justice Umaru Abdullahi, CON, President of the Court of Appeal and others deployed to the Ministry of Justice of North-Central State as its nucleus officers. Hon. Justice Nasir became the Solicitor-General whilst I was his number two as Senior State Counsel. The years 1968 to 1972 saw him and myself working together at very close quarters. During those years I rose to the rank of Principal State Counsel and Solicitor-General. My appointment to the last post did not come about easily.

In 1969, Hon. Justice Mamman Nasir was appointed the first Attorney-General and Commissioner for Justice of the North-Central State. I did not immediately succeed him as Solicitor General. I remained Principal State Counsel until 1971. An incident happened in 1970 when he proposed in the Estimate of the State for the creation of the Office of Solicitor-General, so that I could be promoted to it. While the State Executive Council was considering the proposal, some unfavorable remarks were made against me by the incumbent Military Governor of the State. Hon. Justice Nasir, who was a member of the Executive Council, put up a defence on my behalf. The debate between him and the Governor got heated and Hon. Justice Nasir at one stage threatened to resign his office of Attorney-General.

The incident was leaked to me and knowing how hard I had been working for the State without promotion, I threatened to resign my appointment. It was Hon. Justice Nasir who prevailed on me not to do so, since the Ministry would collapse if both of us left at the same time. Common sense and reason prevailed, the proposal in the Estimate was accepted and immediately the Budget was passed, Hon. Justice Nasir put up a recommendation to the State Civil Service Commission for my promotion and that was how I became the Solicitor-General.

In 1972, I was asked by the Chief Justice of Northern Nigeria, the late Sir Nigel Reed after consultation with Hon. Justice Mamman Nasir, as Attorney-General of North-Central State, whether I would like to go to the North-Eastern State as an Acting Judge of the High Court of that State, in order to help clear the backlog of murder cases in the State, which had then only one High Court Judge in acting capacity. I was then 36 years old. I did not want to go to the Bench then as my ambition was to do so at the age of 45. I was, at that time, enjoying appearing in the Supreme Court and the High Court as counsel. The proposal was not attractive to me even if it was to last for 6 months only as suggested by Sir Nigel Reed, Hon. Justice Mamman Nasir persisted that I should not turn down the invitation since it was a great honor and recognition of my capability. So I accepted the bait and ever since I was not allowed to return to the Ministry of Justice and the Bar which I loved, I remained on the Bench until today.

When late General Murtala Mohammed, a classmate, school housemate of mine at Barewa College, staged a coup d’état in 1975, a Chief Justice (now Chief Judge) was to be appointed for old Kaduna State as the North-Central State later came to be known. Three Judges were to be appointed for the State, we were Hon. Justice A.W.E. Wheeler, late Hon. Justice Shehu Usman Mohammed and myself. Since Hon. Justice Wheeler was senior to both of us and was in fact our training officer in the erstwhile Ministry of Justice of Northem Nigeria, he was proposed for the post of Chief Justice. The Military Governor of the State would rather have an indigene and so nominated me for the office. I had to turn his choice down because my sense of fairness would not allow me to accept the office. And so Hon. Justice Wheeler became the first Chief Justice of Kaduna State. When he went on his 3 months annual leave in May 1976, I was made Acting Chief Justice of the State in his absence.

When the Federal Court of Appeal was created on 1st October of that year. I was the choice of Hon. Justice Arthur Wheeler for appointment to it. However, I was not keen because I did not fancy being posted to all its divisions, which were the 5 regional headquarters of the former Regional Governments of Nigeria. What influenced my mind was the condition of my sick stricken mother in Zaria and the construction of a house which was going on in Kaduna with a loan from the Nigerian Building Society. Nevertheless, I found myself and Hon. Justice Mustapha Akanbi, together with others, appointed to the Court on 1st January, 1977.

Luckily and due to the influence of Hon. Justice Mamman Nasir, who had earlier in November, 1976, became a Justice of the Court, I found myself, with him and late Hon. Justice S. J. Ete, deployed to the branch of the Court in Kaduna. Early in 1978, Hon. Justice D.O. Ibekwe, who was the first President of the Court of Appeal, died. He was succeeded by Hon. Justice Mamman Nasir, who moved to Lagos. Hence, I became the second Presiding Justice of the Court in Kaduna. Hon. Justice Adenekan Ademola, OFR took the place of Hon. Justice Nasir. I variously sat in the Divisions of the Federal Court of Appeal at Lagos, Ibadan and Benin but not Enugu before I was appointed to the Supreme Court on 15th August, 1979, together with late Hon. Justice Augustine Nnamani, JSC.

I was not very happy about the appointment because it was going to take me further away from my sick mother who would not like to leave Zaria or live with me wherever I might be. She too was vehemently against me accepting the appointment. I therefore went to late Sir Darnley Alexander to protest the appointment and lack of consultation with me before it was made. His response to me was that it was too late for me to protest since the appointment had been announced to the whole world and that it was never the practice anywhere, for an officer who was to be promoted to be consulted before being so elevated. I therefore had no choice but to accept my fate. As for my mother, she would have none of it. I had to rely on my maternal uncle, the late Sarkin Auchan, Alhaji Zakari Ya’u, who was her younger brother to prevail on her.

Reluctantly though she gave her blessing after I promised that I would travel to Zaria at the end of every month to see her. So it had been until she died in Zaria on the 20th January 1990, when l happened to be there for the award of honorary degree to late Hon. Justice Mohammed Bello, JSC, GCON, Chief Justice of Nigeria by the Ahmadu Bello University. This gave me opportunity to participate in her funeral. May her soul rest in peace and may Allah (SWT) grant her Aljanah (Paradise). Amen.

Alas, she was not destined to see me become the Chief Justice of Nigeria and thereby observe crowning of the fruits of her labour.

I was appointed as the Chief Justice of Nigeria on 19th December, 1995, after being a Justice of the Supreme Court for 16 years. While being sworn-in on the same day at the State House, Abuja, the Head of State, late Sani Abacha, GCON, in his speech stated as follows:-

“The ceremony which you have just witnessed marks the beginning of a new chapter in the judicial history of our great country. Hon. Justice Mohammed Lawal Uwais, by his appointment as Chief Justice of Nigeria has assumed leadership of the judiciary after 16 years as Justice of the Supreme Court of Nigeria.

The choice of a successor to Hon. Justice Mohammed Bello, as Chief Justice of Nigeria was a painstaking task. Government was mindful of the seniority of the serving members of the Supreme Court and was determined to ensure that the most senior justice of the Supreme Court took over from Honorable Justice Bello after retirement.

Happily, Justice Bello’s successors as we have seen, is no less a legal giant. Justice Mohammed Lawal Uwais’ training, experience and intellectual capacity have adequately prepared him for the exalted office of the Chief Justice of Nigeria.

His rich professional background explains the high expectation engendered by his appointment, especially at this critical time in our history. We expect Justice Uwais will bring his vast experience, maturity and foresight to bear on the judiciary”.

Since my appointment as a Justice of the Supreme Court in 1979, I had the luck to work under no less than 5 Chief Justices of Nigeria. They are Sir Darnley Alexander, GCON, Hon. Justice Atanda Fatayi-Williams GCON, Hon. Justice George Sodeinde Sowemimo, GCON, Hon. Justice Ayo Gabriel Irikefe, GCON and Hon. Justice Mohammed Bello, GCON, all of whom have departed this world. I have also worked at different times with no less than 54 Justices of the Supreme Court.

In my capacity as Chief Justice of Nigeria, I succeeded in bringing about a number of changes in the manner in which the Supreme Court conducts its affairs. In 1998, I was able to convince General Abdulsalami Abubakar as Head of State, to appoint more Justices of Supreme Court. For the first time ever since the 1979 Constitution came into operation, the court got its full complement of 16 Justices. This enabled me to change the sitting arrangement of the Justices c the Court in September to mark the beginning of the legal year and have new Senior Advocate of Nigeria sworn-in. I also introduced 3 terms for the court in the Legal Year, during which arrangements of panel change.

The Chief Justice of Nigeria is the ex-officio Chairman of the National Judicial Council, the Federal Judicial Service Commission, and the Board of Governors of the National Judicial Institute. The administration of these statutory bodies has been most demanding; I have tried my level best in the manner in which I performed the functions.

In reply to my letter of 6″ March, 2006 to His Excellency the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, Chief Olusegun Obasanjo, GCFR, giving him notice of my retirement, he stated as follows in his letter of 2lst April 2006 to me:-

“I note with delight that having traversed the judicial landscape of Nigeria for almost half a century out of which over 27 years have been spent in the Supreme Court, you are retiring in good health, in spite of the turbulent waters of Public Service at the top level. This gives cause for celebration and giving thanks to the Almighty Allah for His blessings.

I must however, admit that your retirement at a time when your Lordship’s experience, hard work, integrity and humility were very much in demand and when the reforms initiated by this Administration, with particular reference to the Judiciary, are beginning to take root, is a great loss to me as a person, the administration and, indeed, Nigeria as a whole.

The return of democratic governance in our country in May 1999 with its emphasis on separation of powers between the Executive, the Legislature and the Judiciary has been a major challenge to all of us especially against the backdrop of military rule for almost two decades, I am however happy to say that under your leadership the Judiciary has been able to restore public confidence in the Judicial process through the enthronement of the rule of law.

Let me at this juncture express the nation’s gratitude to you for the meritorious service you rendered to your fatherland in the past 47 years. Nigeria will certainly miss your exemplary leadership and commitment to the rule of law. It is our hope that the legacy you are leaving behind will continue to be the guiding principles of the Judiciary so that we can move Nigeria forward”.

This should mark the end of this address. However, I need to thank my brothers, Hon. Justices of the Supreme Court for their support and cooperation during the years that we worked together.

As we worked strenuously there had been periods of stresses and pressures which tasked us. But I am glad that we came through all that cheerfully and remained friends, maintaining mutual respect and affection. I will certainly wish to thank all the staff that worked closely with me both alive and dead. Working with me is most demanding but you have weathered it very well.

Whatever success I record, has been in no small measure due to your support and hard work. I will remain ever grateful to you all.

I now come to my dear wives, Hajiya Saratu and Hajia Mariam whom I got married to in January, 1988, as well as my children particularly the youngest ones. You all have been wonderful. You withstood the demands of my office that is the office of Chief Justice of Nigeria. You could not have my attention at most times that you needed it. You suffered in silence Whatever accolade or success I scored, I dedicate all to you. For that would not have been achieved without the love, support and understanding that you showed to me. I pray to Almighty Allah to reward you abundantly, Amen.

This is my story. I have been very lucky in life, Thank to Almighty God.

With these words I come to the end of the address. I thank you all for coming to this special session and for your friendship, admiration and your very kind words. God bless you all.

Alhamdu Lillah.

For Tinubu and Sanwo-Olu

By Lasisi Olagunju

“When lions battle, jackals flee.” Isaac Newton wrote that to his bitter rival, Gottfried Leibniz. It was a barbed remark on their feud over who between them first invented calculus. The more you read of the mutual respect those two had for each other, the more you wonder why they ended their respective careers in very bitter, reckless animosity; the more you also ponder over the cost of that fight and whether it was worth the troubles.

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu and Governor Babajide Sanwo-Olu of Lagos are two big men who are not equals. One is the boss, the other the boss’s boy. They are not equals, so, there cannot be a rivalry between them over feats and achievements. But they fight; and it is right here in the open. I’ve heard people demanding to know what they are fighting over. We do not know. Let no one talk about Lagos speakership. The sack of Mudasiru Obasa, which was as abortive as Dimka’s coup of 1976, was just what it was – a symptom; it was a reaction to something; there was an underlying cause. What was it?

Sanwo-Olu and his boss are no Isaac Newton and Gottfried Leibniz, and so their fight couldn’t be over who takes the priority on a matter designed to help humanity. If there is a delectable Queen Cleopatria somewhere, I would have drawn a parallel between what is unfolding in Lagos and what unfolded between Rome’s Octavian (Augustus Caesar) and Mark Anthony. But there is no seductress in the mix, I will, therefore, not deliver to age what it is no longer capable of tweaking.

So, what did Sanwo-Olu do? Or what did he not do? Both sides are not talking. All we’ve seen was an ungracious rejection of a friendly gesture; the snub of a handshake by the more powerful potentate. We’ve also seen a convenient skip of the junior power where he ought to speak.

Some people are happy, clinking glasses over the power buffetings in Lagos. They drink to the health of the feud; they wish it greater vigour; they wish its fire is unquenchable. These are people who do not like Lagos and its politics at all and who have been their victims. They see the fight as the elixir that would cleanse the land of all its sins and cure it of its sicknesses. They talk of power and its excesses. They point at Akinwumi Ambode, the man who was brought low so that Sanwo-Olu could ride high. They remember Babatunde Fashola, who escaped breathlessly simply because he was like Coca-Cola, more popular and successful than the parent company. They point at a Governor Bola Tinubu of Lagos who serially used three deputy governors in a tenure of eight years. If I were the president, I would also look at these unedifying statistics and repack my big and small intestines.

A leader should be very careful on the way he treats his people, particularly the companions who look up to him. There was an Orangun of Ila who bulldozed his way to power with charms and then elevated the humiliation of his principal chiefs to an art. An Ila historian wrote that the king’s “humiliating treatment (of the chiefs) reached intolerable proportions when he frowned at seeing the Iwarefa (the kingmakers) in decent attires.

When a chief made a new garment, he was obliged to excise the breast and patch it with a rag.” But every reign, no matter how glorious or inglorious, must come to an end. How did it end for that oba? He didn’t die on the throne. His character gave him a fate which made him a farmer outside of power. Ó fi’gbá ìtóòrò mu’mi nínú oko (he drank water with ìtóòrò melon calabash on the farm). I suggest you read ‘The Orangun Dynasty’, a very rich 1996 book on the history of the Igbomina stock of the Yoruba, authored by Ila Orangun’s very first university graduate, Prince Isaac Adebayo; check pages 40 and 41.

A leader is a masquerade; he must not tear his own veil. When a leader makes and unmakes subordinates, he rends his own cover. “Ènìyàn l’aso mi” is a Yoruba expression which, in English means “people are my clothes; they are my covering.” As a Yoruba proverb, it emphasizes the importance of people in people’s lives. Whatever clothes the masquerade wears is that ‘thing’ that makes the wearer an Egungun. He must protect it because it is his store of power. But my people say power is like medicine; it intoxicates. A researcher adds that “ultimately, the accumulation of power becomes dangerous even to its owners.” Is that why someone saw “a link between mask and menace”?

So, when we interrogate the use of power by the one we have come to call Lagos, we should always remind him that the costume is the sacred adornment which people see, respect and venerate in the masquerade. For a leader, his principal boys and girls are his costume, they are his cover. He needs them when harmattan comes with its fury. And harmattan will come whenever the masquerade repairs back to the grove when the festival is over, and it will be over.

Even lions, kings of the jungle, rely on strong bonds within their prides for survival and well-being. There is an old Irving King song on this: “The more we get together/The merrier we’ll be.” That song emphasizes human interconnectedness; the support embedded in community.

Jackals are opportunists, and they are many in this Lagos fight. Newton’s feuding-lion imagery is an evocation of the themes of strength, of hierarchy, and of consequence. It defines the strained relationship of one big expert with the other big man. The other part of his proverb ‘bombs’ the miserable jackals, minions who lurk around the battlefield, who thrive in chaos and on scraps from the feuding powers.

American novelist, Herman Melville, says a thousand fibers connect us with our fellow men. We should not live our lives as if we exist only for ourselves. Public ‘spanking’ of a governor for unknown and unsaid sins is petty. A president should have snubbed rebuff as his option of engagement. If I were him, If a ‘boy’ offended me, I would just ‘face front’ and concentrate on delivering the Chinaware I carry unbroken. If your load is a pot of palm oil, avoid stone throwers.

But the president is not a pacifist. He enjoys fighting wars after wars. He is like Sango, who desperately desired a fight but found no one to fight. Sango looked round and pounced on the wall and wrestled with it. There was also an Aare Ona Kakanfo who itched for a battle and could get none. He stoked a rebellion at home against himself and, by himself, violently put it down. Because of this and many more like it, the man was nicknamed Aburúmáku (the wicked one who refuses to die).

Are there no elders again where the feuding feudal lords come from? Borrowing lines from Ulli Beier, I would say that now that men appear to have failed to stop this war, women should be called upon to come and kill the fire. Our mothers are like Osun, “the wisdom of the forest, the wisdom of the river. Where the doctor failed, she cures with fresh water. Where medicine is impotent, she cures with cool water.”

The first lady should therefore step out, open her Bible (KJV) to Mark 4:39 and read to her husband: “And he arose, and rebuked the wind, and said unto the sea, Peace, be still. And the wind ceased, and there was a great calm.”

If she does that, I will be encouraged to give the president two lines from William Shakespeare: “Come, wife, let’s in, and learn to govern better;/ For yet may England curse my wretched reign” (2 Henry VI, IV, ix, 4).

If our president’s reign won’t be cursed for wretchedness, he should prioritise the people’s welfare over serial petty fights with his boys. Nigerians are panting at home and reeling in pain at work; on the road, they groan. They are not entertained at all by presidential beer parlour brawls like Musician Ayinla Omowura’s last fight. You don’t become king and still keep trysts with crickets. No.

The views expressed by contributors are strictly personal and not of Law & Society Magazine.

Adieu, the quintessential jurist Justice Muhammad Lawal Uwais, CJN, GCON — Izinyon, SAN

By Dr Alex Izinyon, SAN


The glorious exit of this all-around epitome of a legal iconoclast and jurist, though painful as a human experience, calls for a celebration of the life of one of the finest legal minds to have sojourned on this planet.

He was an embodiment of justice, hard work, tenacity of purpose, and an astute judicial administrator whose footprint will remain indelible in the sand of time for many generations both now and hereafter.

I dare say many write-ups on this jurist are inevitable, but none can capture all of this noble jurist. Permit me, therefore, to use the age long jurisprudence of the six blind men of Hindustan and the elephant in this tribute.

Recall the six blind men who were to describe the elephant after their blind encounter took different positions, each arriving at vastly different conclusions on what an elephant is like.

It remains an indisputable aphorism till date used to illustrate the limitations of individual perception and the importance of multiple views in arriving at a complete understanding of things.

I rest on this platform, therefore, to posit just a part of the Hindustan analogy. But unlike the proverbial Hindustan six blind men and the elephant, I have seen with my eyes wide open this part.

Here was a jurist very amiable, effable mien, always full of smiles and pleasantties which do not affect his legal disposition and tenacity of purpose in dispensing justice.

Yes, let me pick these as my own, which I have seen and read about this legal enigma. Adieu, the great law lord.

Dr Alex Izinyon SAN, PhD, OFR

Uwais resisted using his office to favour family and cronies with key appointments in the judiciary during his tenure — Odinkalu

Law teacher and rights Advocate, Prof. Chidi Odinkalu, has made a call to the leadership of Nigeria’s judiciary, urging that they infuse integrity into the system by avoiding cronyism in all ramifications.

Odinkalu, a former chairman of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), warned that cronyism erodes the ethics and integrity of public institutions.

In a post on his verified X handle on Sunday, Odinkalu paid tribute to the onetime Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Muhammadu Uwais, who died on Friday at the age of 88.

He eulogised the late Uwais not only for his brilliance on the bench but also for upholding professionalism and impartiality in the judiciary for the 11 years he spent in office as CJN.

The former NHRC chair and human rights lawyer deplored what he described as the erosion of ethics and the growing nepotism in the judiciary in recent years.

He observed that Uwais’s fidelity to principles enabled him to resist using his office to favour family and cronies with key appointments in the judiciary during his tenure as CJN.

The ever-candid Odinkalu stated that Uwais maintained a strict separation between his official duties and family interests, a standard he said has diminished in the nation’s judiciary after the eminent jurist retired from the Supreme Court in 2006.

“In 27 yrs at @SupremeCourtNg, 11 of which he spent as #CJN, Mohammed Lawal Uwais did not appoint his son, daughter, wife or mistress as judge or SAN. By contrast, Olukayode Ariwoola spent only 2 yrs as CJN & littered the entire place with his family,” he stated.

Odinkalu had consistently spoken against the last leadership at the Supreme Court for appointing several relatives to key offices in the judiciary.

Some of the appointments were made into the bench, the bar and the Supreme Court bureaucracy.

According to him, such appointments often stand in the way of integrity, neutrality and professionalism in the justice system.