Home Blog Page 414

A day’s affair of a Jewish and Muslim calling in Morocco

By Yossef Ben-Meir
Marrakech

This article describes a day in December when the Moroccan Jewish community implemented restoration work of its High Atlas cemetery in Tafza, carried out by members of local farming families. This joint local action crystalizes the sublime Moroccan Jewish and Muslim national experience.

On the 12th of December 2024, I set out with four colleagues of the High Atlas Foundation (HAF) to meet with members of the rural community of Tafza (Al Haouz province, Marrakesh region), located in the mountain range that bore the horrendous epicenter of the September 2023 earthquake. Unlike the countless visits that members of our Moroccan and US non-profit organization have made to many hundreds of village communities in this area since that natural disaster, this recent December visit was of a different, yet still humanly essential, restoration purpose

The president of the Moroccan Jewish community in Marrakesh, Jacky Kadoch, followed by the authorization of the provincial governing authorities, had asked that we perform a sacred duty at the Tafza Jewish cemetery. Our purpose that day was to gather and bury again the human bone remains that have emerged from the ground from the years of terrible erosion, likely exacerbated by the previous year’s earthquake.

The High Atlas Foundation’s re-tombing of the beloved departed, upon request, is an honoured service that we perform with urgency. HAF implements community development projects based on the local people’s collective will for initiatives that meet their individual and shared priority needs.

Our best expertise is in facilitating those introspective conversations that result in the peoples’—the beneficiaries’—action plan for the development they want most of all. For us, and as is underscored by global experience, projects endure and meet the people’s goals of their lives because of the communities’ dedication in carrying them out. It is therefore vital that the re-tombing be done together with the people in closest proximity to the historic mountain cemetery since doing so also holds importance for them.

The Sunni Muslim Kingdom of Morocco’s caretaking of Jewish cemeteries in all parts of the nation comes as naturally as the peoples’ identity itself may come. It requires no explanation, no persuasion, only the confirmation of a day and a time when men of all ages gather to restore what the collective community sees as part of their own indelible and revered past. When we arrived that morning, roughly 30 people were already gathered with their tools to traverse the 1,200-square-meter cemetery, pick up every observed bone, place them in a cloth sack or covering (as per Moroccan Jewish and Muslim traditions), and re-bury them in a new grave that Tafza residents had dug, lined with brick, and built to endure for the next millennia.

As we walked together with Tafza people in all parts of the cemetery with our eyes to the ground, we also spoke about the work needed to redress and end the erosion of this degrading mountain slope. We identified the critical points at which to add and level soil and plant non-bearing fruit trees in a manner allowable by Jewish custom. We spoke about the three Jewish village communities who left the area several generations ago to which this circa 1,000-year-old cemetery belonged. We went to the unmarked burial site of a revered rabbi, whose name this adult generation of Tafza people no longer recall. Most local oracles of knowledge about this cemetery, great grandparents of today’s farming families, are no longer alive.

We addressed the exigency of bone reburial, but an enormity of restoration work remains. Even with the highly commendable national initiative of the Moroccan Jewish community led by Serge Berdugo with financial backing of the Moroccan government following Royal instructions that restored 167 Jewish cemeteries, a large number still require attention.

The Moroccan government representatives’ presence that morning was warm, helpful, and kindred. It felt as if all together we had created that day a subcommunity of Moroccan protectors of the past and future. It is a Moroccan Jewish custom at the anniversary of the passing of their righteous ones (the occasion referred to as a hiloula) to eat together and enjoy a shared moment of bounty. On that December day, it was not an anniversary of anyone passing, though it might have been. But we did break bread, dipped it in local raw honey and olive oil, drank tea made with local herbs, and shared a moment atop infinite previous moments of Moroccan Muslim and Jewish people from government, civil society, and small businesses, from city and rural places, completing something that was calling to be done.

We brought before all of our eyes the miracles and blessings of Morocco that find their way into our daily affairs. It explains for me, as well as I have been able, that to serve in Morocco is to never let go.

Dr. Yossef Ben-Meir is a sociologist, a former Peace Corps Volunteer who served in the High Atlas Mountains 30 years ago, and President of the High Atlas Foundation in Morocco.

Married father of two stabs ex-girlfriend to death over failed attempt to revive relationship

A 38-year-old man identified as Bill Jallah has stabbed his ex-girlfriend, Princess Zuo, to death in Liberia. 

Witnesses detailed that the incident occurred late Saturday evening, December 21, 2024, at a local Entertainment Center in Paynesville. 

It was gathered that the attack occurred after Zuo refused to reconcile with him. 

Further reports indicated that the relationship between the deceased and Jallah who is married with two kids, collapsed after his wife rendered several death threats to the late Princess Zuo.

According to reports, threats from Jallah’s wife made Princes afraid, hence she decided to put an end to the relationship.

It was reported that the Jallah and Princess had been on a breakup for a month, when the late Princess had decided to abort Jallah’s calls and refused to respond to his text messages, which had the relationship dormant until the suspect’s sister asked to Intervene in the relationship at a nearby entertainment center, where the incident occurred.

She was reportedly stabbed multiple times in her stomach, her neck, and her back, resulting in her death.

The suspect has since been apprehended by the police, while Princess’s body has been deposited at a local funeral home as the investigation continues. 

Liberia: Married father of two stabs ex-girlfriend to d3ath after failed attempt to rekindle relationship
Liberia: Married father of two stabs ex-girlfriend to d3ath after failed attempt to rekindle relationship
Liberia: Married father of two stabs ex-girlfriend to d3ath after failed attempt to rekindle relationship

Nigerian widow accuses brothers-in-law of taking over her late husband’s house, changing locks

A Nigerian widow, Uba Princess Chidinma Ugoji, has accused her brothers-in-law of taking over her late husband’s house, leaving her and her children homeless. 

Lamenting her ordeal in a Facebook post on Tuesday, December 24, 2024, the mother of four said her late husband’s brothers allegedly went to the house in her absence and threw her staff and younger sister out.

She also claimed that they changed the locks on the house and went away with the documents after threatening to kill her if she approached the property. 

“It’s not my wish to become a widow at this time leaving this innocent 3 little boys and our adopted daughter for only me to carter for, God decided to call my dear husband home on time, away from sickness and pains. But it will be an error for I Uba Princess Chidinma Ugoji to fold my arms and allow my late husband brothers take away what their late father and I laboured for,” she wrote.  

“Since last week I have been denied access to the home I live with my children, my husband brothers went to my house with men of the under world thinking I was inside so that they can end my life and that of my children, unfortunately for them they met my absence inside my compound but unleashed their anger on my staff and my younger sister went away with documents, pushed them out my home almost naked and gave a stern warning that I shouldn’t come close to my house if I don’t want to my family to come carry my dead body. 

“As if that wasn’t enough, they changed my house keys and locked I and my kids outside. With the help of the Nigeria police, they were able to apprehend them yesterday and took one of them to my house and made him unlock their keys so that I and my kids can have access to my house.

“I never knew this is what young widows go through in the hands of some Mbano people. Death!!!!! You do this one.” 

They changed the keys and locked me and my kids outside  - Nigerian widow accuses brothers-in-law of taking over her late husband

Linda Ikeji

Bishop Kukah says failure of government behind hunger crisis, tragic stampedes

  • Nigerians don’t like to queue; organisers made grave errors – Tinubu

Bishop of Sokoto Diocese, Mathew Hassan Kukah, has blamed the government for the hunger crisis that led to recent stampedes in Abuja, Oyo, and Anambra States, claiming innocent lives during food distribution.

In his Christmas message, Bishop Kukah criticised the government’s inaction, describing the tragedies as a “metaphor for the situation of despair” gripping the nation.

“The tragedies that occurred in Okija, Ibadan, and Abuja where innocent people lost their lives in stampedes at food distribution points are a metaphor for the situation of desperation that citizens have been thrown into. The failures of government to respond concretely toward ending the horrible crisis of hunger and desperation has created the conditions for these avoidable tragedies,” he stated.

He urged the government to collaborate with institutions committed to societal welfare and ensure citizens live with dignity.

The Bishop also reflected on Nigeria’s progress since independence, stating that the nation continues to “walk in darkness” due to entrenched issues such as ethnicity, nepotism, and greed.

“Our journey to greatness is still severely constrained by the forces of ethnicity, nepotism, and greed,” he remarked, adding that these forces exacerbate feelings of exclusion and violence among citizens.

Bishop Kukah also addressed barriers to youth participation in politics, citing the high cost of running for office as a persistent challenge, despite the passage of the Not Too Young to Run Bill.

On education, he commended the government for introducing loan schemes but stressed the importance of extending such opportunities to vocational and technical students while removing bureaucratic obstacles.

“In future, poverty should not exclude anyone from a good education. We encourage the youth to seize this opportunity with both hands,” he said.

While acknowledging progress in combating insecurity, he called for a detailed national security plan addressing unemployment and religious extremism to ensure lasting peace.

“Insecurity is the first child of corruption. We cannot win the war against insecurity without addressing the issues of unemployment and violent religious extremism which create the conditions for violence,” he added.

Bishop Kukah’s message served as both a critique of government shortcomings and a call to action for a brighter and more inclusive future for Nigeria.

President Bola Tinubu however blamed the masses and organisers for the stampedes that occurred during palliative distribution in Ibadan, Abuja and Anambra last week. The president stated Nigerians don’t like to queue, saying that it reflects in our bus stops.

Tinubu made these remarks during his first Presidential Media Chat in Lagos on Monday, blaming the organisers of the giveaways for the tragedies, which claimed the lives of more than 50 Nigerians, including children.

“It reflects in our bus stops where we don’t even like to be in the queue before we rush into the vehicle. It is very sad, but we will continue to learn from our mistakes.

“To me, I see this as a very great error on the part of the organisers but things are improving and it doesn’t kill our happiness,” Tinubu said.

While sympathising with the families of the victims, Tinubu dismissed the claim that the stampedes were caused by hunger and economic hardships. He said there are food banks in the United Kingdom and the United States but stampedes don’t happen there.

Credits: Vanguard Newspaper and BusinessDay

Wealthy gay couple who sexually abused adopted sons to spend 100 years in jail

A wealthy gay couple who repeatedly molested their adopted sons have been sentenced to 100 years in prison.

Zachary and William Zulock will spend the rest of their lives behind bars after pleading guilty to multiple charges including aggravated sodomy and child molestation. They are believed to have abused the boys since they were three and five years old.

Police recovered surveillance footage from their family home, in an affluent suburb of Atlanta, Georgia, of the pair sexually abusing their adopted sons.

Randy McGinley, the local district attorney, said the two men had created a “house of horrors” where they “put their extremely dark desires above everything and everyone else”, the MailOnline reported.

The Zulocks had cultivated an image of a perfect family life, with both Zachary, a 36-year-old bank worker, and William, a 34-year-old government employee, posting photos on social media which showed them with their sons in matching rainbow T-shirts.

According to screenshots posted online, the men had posed for the anti-homophobia campaign #NoH8.

The Daily Wire also reported that Out magazine, a prominent LGBT publication, had asked to feature their photos on its website.

The Zulocks adopted their sons, now 10 and 12, from a Christian special-needs agency which has since gone out of business.

The pair spoke about and sent images of their abuse to two other paedophiles, one of whom told the police that they had offered the boys to him “multiple times”.

Zachary is said to have been reported to police for allegedly raping another boy in 2011, although charges were never brought.

“The depth of the defendants’ depravity, which is as deep as it gets, is not greater than the resolve of those that fought for justice and the strength of the victims in this case,” Mr McGinley said.

“The resolve I have seen from these two young victims over the last two years is truly inspiring.”

In August 2024, William pleaded guilty to aggravated sodomy, child molestation, incest and two counts of sexual exploitation of children.

Zachary pleaded guilty in October to aggravated sodomy, child molestation and sexual exploitation of children, and was subsequently found guilty on two counts of incest.

Both will almost certainly die in prison, having been sentenced to 100 years behind bars without the possibility of parole.

A wealthy gay couple who repeatedly molested their adopted sons have been sentenced to 100 years in prison.

Zachary and William Zulock will spend the rest of their lives behind bars after pleading guilty to multiple charges including aggravated sodomy and child molestation. They are believed to have abused the boys since they were three and five years old.

Police recovered surveillance footage from their family home, in an affluent suburb of Atlanta, Georgia, of the pair sexually abusing their adopted sons.

Randy McGinley, the local district attorney, said the two men had created a “house of horrors” where they “put their extremely dark desires above everything and everyone else”, the MailOnline reported.

The Zulocks had cultivated an image of a perfect family life, with both Zachary, a 36-year-old bank worker, and William, a 34-year-old government employee, posting photos on social media which showed them with their sons in matching rainbow T-shirts.

According to screenshots posted online, the men had posed for the anti-homophobia campaign #NoH8.

The Daily Wire also reported that Out magazine, a prominent LGBT publication, had asked to feature their photos on its website.

The Zulocks adopted their sons, now 10 and 12, from a Christian special-needs agency which has since gone out of business.

The pair spoke about and sent images of their abuse to two other paedophiles, one of whom told the police that they had offered the boys to him “multiple times”.

Zachary is said to have been reported to police for allegedly raping another boy in 2011, although charges were never brought.

“The depth of the defendants’ depravity, which is as deep as it gets, is not greater than the resolve of those that fought for justice and the strength of the victims in this case,” Mr McGinley said.

“The resolve I have seen from these two young victims over the last two years is truly inspiring.”

In August 2024, William pleaded guilty to aggravated sodomy, child molestation, incest and two counts of sexual exploitation of children.

Zachary pleaded guilty in October to aggravated sodomy, child molestation and sexual exploitation of children, and was subsequently found guilty on two counts of incest.

Both will almost certainly die in prison, having been sentenced to 100 years behind bars without the possibility of parole.

Culled from Telegraph UK

Ambulance Chasing: A reprehensible form of professional misconduct

By E. Monjok Agom

The legal profession is built on a foundation of trust, integrity, and ethical behaviour. However, there exist some unscrupulous individuals who engage in reprehensible practices that bring the profession into disrepute. One such practice is ambulance chasing, a form of professional misconduct that is condemned by legal practitioners and regulators alike.

THE VIRAL STORY THAT SPARKED CONCERN

Recently, a viral story emerged of some lawyers in Lagos who were arraigned for touting and fighting over clients. This shocking incident highlighted the need to reawaken the ethical consciousness of legal practitioners in Nigeria. The story served as a stark reminder that the legal profession is not immune to unethical behaviour and that urgent action is needed to address this issue.

DEFINING AMBULANCE CHASING

Ambulance chasing refers to the unethical practice of soliciting or pursuing clients, particularly those involved in accidents or other traumatic events, for the purpose of offering legal services. This practice typically involves a range of unprofessional and exploitative tactics, including:

Solicitation: Actively seeking out potential clients, often at the scene of an accident or in hospitals.

  • Coercion or manipulation: Using coercive or manipulative tactics to persuade the potential client to retain their services.
  • Lack of regard for the client’s best interests: Prioritising the lawyer’s own interests over those of the client.

REGULATORY FRAMEWORK

In Nigeria, the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners (2007) specifically prohibit ambulance chasing. Rule 39 of the Rules provides that a lawyer may engage in advertising or promotion in connection with his practice, provided it is fair and proper in all circumstances and complies with the provisions of the Rules.

However, Rule 39(2) prohibits a awyer from engaging in any advertisement or promotion that:

  • Is inaccurate or likely to mislead
  • Is likely to diminish public confidence in the legal profession or the administration of justice
  • Makes comparison with or criticizes other lawyers or professions
  • Includes any statement about the quality of the lawyer’s work or success rate
  • Is so frequent or obstructive as to cause annoyance

Furthermore, Rule 39(3) specifically prohibits a lawyer from soliciting professional employment through:

Circulars, handbills, or advertisements

Touts or personal communication or interview

  • Newspaper, radio, or television comments
  • Procuring his photograph to be published in connection with his practice
  • Sound recordings in relation to his practice

EXCEPTIONS

Sub-rule (4) of Rule 39 provides exceptions to the prohibition on solicitation, including:

  • Responding to inquiries from prospective clients
  • Participating in legal aid programs
  • Providing information to the public through public lectures or writings
  • Participating in bar association or law society activities
  • Responding to requests from other lawyers for referrals

CONCLUSION

Ambulance chasing is a reprehensible form of professional misconduct that undermines the integrity of the legal profession. Lawyers who engage in this practice risk disciplinary action, including suspension or disbarment. It is essential for lawyers to adhere to the highest standards of professional conduct and to prioritise the best interests of their clients at all times. The viral story of the lawyers in Lagos serves as a stark reminder of the need for ethical consciousness in the legal profession.

E. Monjok Agom
25th December, 2024

Background

Eight Lagos Lawyers got into trouble for allegedly quarrelling and scrambling for clients at the Court premises. They were eventually arrested by the Police and later arraigned before the Court for constituting public nuisance.

The lawyers are: Dowu Okuwanne, f,41, Opara Chinwe, f,47, Moses Akpasubi, m,51, Jolly Ogbuefi, m, 49, Adebayo Olowofela, m, 39, Kayode Akintau, m, 45, Celine Nwosu f, 41 and Olawale Olayinka, f, 59.

The Presiding Magistrate, Her Worship, Tanimola, granted them bail on recognisance and ordered them to produce their Call to Bar certificates as proof that they were actually lawyers and called to the Bar.

[Video] Rufai Oseni shreds Tinubu’s maiden presidential media chat

Arise News Television anchor, Rufai Oseni has described President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s recent media chat as disappointing and alarming.

Oseni shared his views during a live broadcast- The Morning Show- where he expressed his dissatisfaction with Tinubu’s performance during the media chat.

Adequate healthcare is human rights

By Prof. Adenike Grange

We are aware that quite a number of other professional groups and civil societies have held webinars on this year’s UHC theme which is ‘Health as the Responsibility of Government”. We realise that Universal Health Coverage is defined as ensuring that all individuals and communities receive the healthcare services they need without suffering financial hardship.

It encompasses access to essential health services, including preventive, promotional, curative, rehabilitative, and palliative care, as well as to safe, effective, quality, and affordable medicines and vaccines. At this webinar, our objective is to source for information at the State and Community levels from highly informed professionals who are working at these levels as service providers, trainers, administrators, advocates, civil society organisations including the organization of patients.

I shall not bore you with the health statistics of Nigeria. Those that are available can be accessed easily. We have come a long way but, there are still many gaps between what is available and what should be available and accessible for better planning purposes. Maybe, we can hope for a closure of this gap with the advent of the internet and the social media when used responsibly. Improvement in the registration of the basic data such as accurate Births and Deaths registrations may also improve the quality of health statistics with time.

2. Indeed, the Health of all Nigerian citizens is the Responsibility of Government.  The right to healthcare is articulated in The Nigerian Constitution, Chapter II, Section 17. This section deals with the “Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy”

Specifically, it outlines the rights related to health and healthcare. It emphasizes that the state shall direct its policy towards ensuring that there are adequate medical and health facilities for all persons.

Whilst it has been noted that these provisions cannot be enforced in the court of law, they serve as guidelines for the government in formulating policies and laws related to the delivery of health and other social services. The Nigerian Health Act, 2014, and one of its components the Basic Health Care Provision Fund Act (BHCPF) are two important specific legislative derivations of these provisions.

The lack of justiciability of these constitutional provisions impacts the ability of citizens to assert and protect their rights, thus affecting the effectiveness of the legal framework in promoting justice and equity.

Unfortunately, over the past five decades of my practice in Nigeria, I have witnessed the gradual erosion of the process to make possible the right of access to quality and affordable health care to the point where it is guaranteed only to political leaders who no longer patronize the healthcare system in Nigeria but they waste no time in jetting abroad to patronize the system that is partially serviced by highly qualified Nigerian doctors and nurses.

Nigeria’s political leaders’ response to this “JAPA” syndrome is to deny these well-trained professionals from leaving Nigeria in search of merit-based positions abroad. How about providing the enabling environment here in Nigeria? Our leaders must learn from low/middle income countries that have successfully reversed the outward migration of their professionals. India is a case in point. They should consider other options that will create a win-win situation for all Nigerians. How about providing a sustainable enabling environment for the trained health human resource in Nigeria?

Our political leaders and public officers must learn how to do this from the experiences of other low-middle income countries that have successfully reversed the outward migration of their health professionals. India is a case in point. India over the past three decades has developed its healthcare system from a grossly underperforming one to one that has now earned its recognition globally as a reliable destination for Medical Tourism. As essential components of health care development are the development of the basic infrastructures including sustained power supply, internet connectivity, safe transportation, legal frameworks for ensuring safety and peaceful resolution of conflicts, security and freedom of movement, food security, stability in the prices and quality of drugs and other commodities.

Our immediate Deputy Head of State, Professor Osibajo deserves to be commended for entrusting his care to the Nigerian healthcare system during an alleged health problem which required a major surgical intervention. Unfortunately, his acclamation of the excellent care he received from a private hospital in Nigeria went unnoticed by the political elites. In recognition of the potential enhancement of the development of public-private partnerships especially for tertiary health care, Government should introduce attractive incentives for qualified practitioners, usually from the Diaspora, who would like to invest in setting up this type of resource-intensive health care delivery system.

As one of the many surviving elderly Nigerian healthcare professionals, I would like to bring forward one glaring fact. That is, many of today’s Nigerian politicians were saved from perishing in their mothers’ wombs and during childhood through the hard work and expert interventions of several generations of dedicated Nigerian doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals. How did they do it? Being one of them I can testify to the better character of politicians and senior administrators of those days. There was equity in remuneration for work done.

Both the professionals and the political leaders rode in the same type of vehicle- for example, the Peuguot 404. There was mutual understanding and respect among healthcare professionals, administrators and politicians. Nowadays, the total remuneration of a legislator is at least five times that of a Professor of Medicine and Chief Consultant who is responsible for the expert medical care of patients. This makes legislators feel superior and they are constantly striving to attain the highest level of wealth accumulation effortlessly to the diminution of the remunerative power of other hardworking citizens whom they are supposed to represent in Congress. 

In those days, 70’s and 80’s, there was empathy for the patients. The Heads of State attended our conferences to listen to and act on our recommendations for improving the healthcare delivery services. It was because of our collective advocacy effort that General Ibrahim Babangida head hunted in 1985 my mentor, late Professor Olikoye Ransome-Kuti, a doyen of Paediatrics for the post of the Minister of Health; he has since been recognized as the most impactful Minister of Health in Nigeria.

Subsequently, I was also humbly privileged to have been headhunted by President Umaru Yar’Adua in 2007 to serve as his Minister of Health. During his tenure, he was unfortunately unable to control his administration to drive the process of transformation effectively due to his ill health which tragically had a fatal ending. As a result of this, my effort to continue with the transformative process begun by my predecessors was brought to an untimely and unfulfilled end. The Heads of States of those days who are still alive today can testify to this narrative.

We, the survivors of that period have been kept alive by the Grace of God for a purpose and that purpose must be fulfilled to His Glory. Nigeria was great then. We know what to do if we really want Nigeria to become great again and to retain its meritorious human capital within its shores. There are documents, policies and programmes galore in every government and academic institution to guide us and now we have digital support which has facilitated the retrieval and sharing of knowledge.

What is required is the humility to recognise, collaborate and coordinate all valuable contributions of the past as well as the present to build the platform on which to remodel the prospects for enhanced and sustainable improvement in the future. Let us not waste any more time and money in retracing our steps from this precipice that would most likely lead us to total disintegration and destruction. The time to have begun our transformation back to our lost glory was yesterday but it is never too late to start.

My passion to witness during my lifetime a healthcare delivery system that can guarantee Universal Health Care (UHC) for the entire population remains unshaken. I know that this passion is shared by the ACTIVE members of NUHCAN. This is the reason why we are at this Webinar- to take stock of our progress so far with a view to consolidating on notable areas of improvement and BRIDGING THE GAPS WHEREVER NEEDED. It is only in this way that we can remain motivated and keep hope alive for the future of our generations yet unborn!

I shall end this rather grim welcome speech by quoting the futuristic words of the third stanza of our Nigerian National Anthem:

“O God of all creation,
Grant this our one request,
Help us to build a nation
Where no man is oppressed,
And so with peace and plenty
Nigeria may be blessed.”

All those who mean well for Nigeria should re-echo this prayer constantly to reinforce our belief that the rebuilding of our nation is in our hands-everyone of us. Yes, we can rebuild it successfully and sustainably!

Thank you for listening!

Professor Adenike Grange,  Chairman of the BOT of NUHCAN

Welcome address presented at NUC Day Webinar by Nigeria Universal Healthcare Advocacy Network (NUHCAN) on 17th December, 2024

Human rights in crisis: Addressing the challenges facing Nigeria (3)

By Ebun-Olu Adegboruwa, SAN

  1. Administration of Justice Crisis:

Human Rights have suffered severe crises due to issues and challenges affecting the administration of justice generally but criminal justice to be precise. Such challenges include but are not limited to the following factors:

  • Indigence: Most citizens cannot afford the cost of pursuing a legal remedy in the event of a violation of their rights. This has to do with the issue of unfettered access to justice as the cost of acquiring legal education is prohibitive and it costs even more to sustain the type of legal practice that will be effective. In total, the government has to do more than the present template to support access to justice. Interventionist organisations such as the Legal Aid Council, Office of the Public Defender, and Citizens Mediation Centre need robust legislation that will give validity to their efforts in addition to adequate funding.
  • Delays: there is a rising incidence of delays in judicial proceedings due to several factors such as an overload of court dockets without adequate judicial manpower, absence of critical infrastructure, especially power supply, machines and equipment and shortage of manpower. This should be addressed holistically in order to achieve effectiveness in the administration of justice sector
  • Bail: The conditions for bail and release of citizens under trial are too stringent and they do not seem to recognize the provisions of the Constitution on presumption of innocence before trial. If bail is recognized as part of the enforcement of the right to personal liberty, there is no need to impose onerous conditions to admit a citizen on bail pending his trial.
  • Unlawful Detention/Prison Congestion: Many of the detainees in the various correctional centres all over Nigeria have been awaiting trial for years and they are languishing in overcrowded facilities built since the colonial period. The reports suggest that over 70% of prisoners are on remand. Reputable groups like Amnesty International highlight instances of prisoners being detained for decades without trial, in circumstances wherein they may be acquitted after trial.
  • Mass Illiteracy: There is the problem of mass legal illiteracy as many people are not even aware of the existence of their Human Rights or are not able to fight for their rights. This has led to denial of rights, extortion and even death in severe cases. Organisations with a track record of human rights protection should take the campaign to the grassroots for the benefit of the masses which constitute the bulk of victims of human rights abuses.
  • Mass Distrust: Due to lack of confidence in the justice system based on some of the discouraging factors, citizens now take the law into their own hands rather than pursuing justice. Individual activists seem to achieve speedy results through spirited campaigns in the social media than the regular courts. Sadly too, a good number of our citizens also troop to the security agencies to resolve their civil disputes instead of following the much-trumpeted due process of law.
  • State-Actor Interference: The state actors and even non-state actors are muzzling the citizens. A police officer raped a detainee/suspect to the point of coma, suspects are not safe in the custody of the state, the privacy of citizens is invaded recklessly by searching their phones and other valuables, status profiling of youths based on their physical appearances. There should be a written code for state actors and non-state actors to guide their interactions with the citizens in such a way that will guarantee and preserve the fundamental rights of all persons.
  1. Security Agencies Crisis:

Closely knit with the crises associated with the administration of justice are the challenges induced by security agencies in Nigeria. Nigerian security agencies especially the police have literally become synonymous with impunity and brutality, which is rather unfortunate considering the fact that the law establishing these agencies requires them to preserve law and order. Some of these problems include:

Usurpation: It is not uncommon nowadays for security agencies to usurp the jurisdiction of courts both in civil and criminal matters. Many of them defy the jurisdiction of courts by going ahead to violate the rights to the dignity of the human person, liberty; fair hearing etc through unlawful arrest and detention of litigants in respect of causes that have been submitted to the jurisdiction of the court. Besides, law enforcement agencies have formed the habit of violating the orders of court inordinately.

Criminalization of Civil Disputes: Security agencies, as a matter of course, frequently arrest and detain citizens at the instigation of private citizens who are on a mission of vendetta against their perceived enemies. Law enforcement agencies make themselves willing collaborators in the hands of unscrupulous private individuals. As such, they put criminal connotations on otherwise civil causes. There are cases of forced evictions and use of police for land grabbing, marital disputes and unlawful execution of improperly obtained court orders.

Extra-Judicial Killings: There is the unfortunate harvest of extra-judicial killings some of which are even engineered and/or sponsored by state actors. For instance, in respect of the ENDSARS Protest, it is now confirmed by an official of the Lagos State Government that people were hunted down and executed, confirming the report of the ENDSARS Panel.

Persecution rather that Prosecution: In many instances, the real facts of some cases that have found themselves in the dockets of the criminal courts are purely instigated by parties to civil disagreements. The state and its agencies should act on behalf of society at large and not become willing tools of oppression. The trinity concept of justice for the complainant, the victim and society at large, should always guide the prosecutors.

iii.         Bar Crisis:

Unfortunately, the Bar itself has also contributed to the growing incidence of HRs crisis. We would have thought that the Bar ought to be a redeeming element in the crisis but unfortunately, many of our colleagues are complicit in the HRs crisis. A chief factor here is the NBA’s growing inactivity. While we must say kudos to the endeavours of the NBA in keeping with the objectives of its constitution to uphold HRs, there is indeed a great need to expedite action in its crusade against HRs violations by intensifying efforts towards activities such as prison visitations, legal aid through pro bono cases; encouragement of Public Interest Litigation; unanimous condemnation of and resistance against executive rascality and interference with the judiciary.

  1. Press Freedom and Public Interest Litigation Crisis: There is also the growing wave of crackdown on free press and Public Interest Litigation. News houses and PIL institutions such as SERAP have encountered relentless resistance, especially from state actors. However, aggressive resilience to repel these forces through solidarity from the HRs stakeholders such as the NBA in partnership with the judiciary will make a strong tag team against these forces.
  1. Possible solutions to the challenges in the Nigerian context

Nigeria is unarguably a member of and subscriber to the UN and the UDHR. It has a mandate to uphold HRs to the maximum. Some critical reformative measures that must be taken to stem the tides of HRs abuse are suggested below:

  1. Call for Reform of NBA Members: That there now exists the Judas-Branch among the NBA brotherhood has become a commonplace thing. Situations where lawyers collude with litigants to abuse the HRs of fellow citizens is most pathetic. It is lawyers who author false petitions on behalf of clients; it is lawyers who fail to advise their clients to cease and desist from criminalizing purely civil causes and it is lawyers who bait the police. Some of our colleagues often encourage the impunity of deploying the instrumentality of law enforcement agencies to pursue a private vendetta. The point is that members of the Bar should have deep self-evaluation leading to the reformation of their practice.
  2. Creation of a Court with Special HRs Jurisdiction: Just like the National Industrial Courts and Family Courts, it is suggested that moves should be made to champion the creation of courts with special HRs jurisdiction. The Court shall be exclusively dedicated to the expeditious hearing and disposal of HRs causes. It is suggested that the NBA should take the lead in this regard. In the interim, it is strongly urged on the NBA to work with the courts to prioritize hearing of HRs cases.

iii.  Making Chapter 2 of the Constitution Justiciable: We submit that if the crusade of HRs would outgrow its present adolescence the relevant portions of Chapter 2 of the Constitution on the Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy should be made justiciable just like Chapter 4 thereof.

  1. HRs Education: Due to the tremendous amount of mass illiteracy, it is suggested that the NBA in collaboration with advocacy groups, should facilitate translation of Chapter 4 of the Constitution into major local languages and circulate the same. That way, a large number of the uneducated masses would become informed about their HRs and understand the opportunity they have to seek redress through the law in the event of violations.
  2. Revival of the NBA Visitation Committee: It is advocated that NBA should revive its visitation committees. At the next AGC, a session should be dedicated to meeting all Branch chairmen to coordinate this process. Also, NBA should encourage interaction with the police and law enforcement agencies for workshops and trainings on HRs by law experts
  1. Conclusion:

As we join the HRs global family to commemorate the 76th episode of the HRs Day with the theme: Our Rights, Our Future, Right Now, we must remember that our attitude to securing our rights by standing up courageously against the forces and crises that beleaguer our rights will determine the kind of future we bequeath to our children. The hands of all stakeholders, particularly the Bar, must be on deck to collectively repel the forces that have come against the crusade for progress and security of Human Rights.

Right of Reply: As LPDC Rejects Afe Babalola’s petition against Dele Farotimi

By Nkereuwem Udofia Akpan

Someone wrote a book and you are reporting him to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) alleging that his actions constitute “professional misconduct” and that the author should be disbarred.

What the LPDC has done in legal terms is an Order striking out the petition as not only lacking in merit but also constituting a gross abuse of its processes.

Secondly, by so doing LPDC has now established a precedent that literally works by legal practitioners are protected as intellectual property, outside the realm of conventional legal practice, and, to that extent, cannot be classified as (or constitute) infamous conduct in a professional respect.

Put differently, writing a book cannot be”infamous conduct in a professional respect”

Sincerely Farotimi has used this book to win so much that he might have lost in the courts.

Whatever the eventual outcome of the hydra-headed claims in multiple venues against Dele Farotimi, what he has achieved so much already can never be undone.

From where I’m standing this is just the beginning of the many victories of Dele Farotimi in the course of these disputes with Aare Afe Babalola SAN and his illustrious Law firm

Chief Nkereuwem Udofia Akpan Constitutional Lawyer
Author and Human Rights Activist writes from Abuja
@chiefnkereuwem on X formerly Twitter

TIPS