Home Blog Page 270

Australian top lawyer apologises after filing AI-generated submissions in Victorian murder case

Rishi Nathwani KC has apologised for filing AI-generated information Credit: ABC News: Kristian Silva .jpeg

A senior defence lawyer, Rishi Nathwan, has apologised to a Victorian judge in Australia for filing submissions in a murder case that included fake quotes and non-existent case judgements generated by artificial intelligence (AI). 

Nathwani, who holds the title of King’s Counsel, took “full responsibility” for filing incorrect information in submissions in the case of a teenager charged with murder, according to court documents seen by The Associated Press on Friday.

“We are deeply sorry and embarrassed for what occurred,” Mr Nathwani told Justice James Elliott on Wednesday, on behalf of the defence team.

The AI-generated errors caused a 24-hour delay in resolving a case that Justice Elliott had hoped to conclude on Wednesday. 

He later ruled on Thursday that Mr Nathwani’s client, who cannot be identified because he is a minor, was not guilty of murder because of mental impairment.

“At the risk of understatement, the manner in which these events have unfolded is unsatisfactory,” Justice Elliott told lawyers on Thursday.

“The ability of the court to rely upon the accuracy of submissions made by counsel is fundamental to the due administration of justice.”

The fake submissions included fabricated quotes from a speech to the state legislature and non-existent case citations purportedly from the Supreme Court.

The errors were discovered by the Justice’s associates, who couldn’t find the cases and requested that defence lawyers provide copies.

The lawyers admitted the citations “do not exist” and that the submission contained “fictitious quotes”, court documents say.

The lawyers explained they checked that the initial citations were accurate and wrongly assumed the others would also be correct.

The submissions were also sent to prosecutor Daniel Porceddu, who did not check their accuracy.

The judge noted that the Supreme Court released guidelines last year for the use of AI by lawyers.

“It is not acceptable for artificial intelligence to be used unless the product of that use is independently and thoroughly verified,” Justice Elliott said.

The court documents do not identify the generative AI system used by the lawyers.

In a comparable case in the United States in 2023, a federal judge imposed $US5,000 ($7,600) fines on two lawyers and a law firm after ChatGPT was blamed for their submission of fictitious legal research in an aviation injury claim.

British High Court Justice Victoria Sharp warned in June that providing false material as if it were genuine could be considered contempt of court or, in the “most egregious cases”, perverting the course of justice, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison.

AP

Bus Terminals: Our FG in Agbero business

By Suyi Ayodele

After settling KWAM 1 with ambassadorial epaulettes, it appears that the National Union of Road Transport Workers (NURTW) President, MC Oluomo, is next to receive Baba’s blessings. With the approval of the Federal Executive Council (FEC) at its meeting last week, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu will be building six motor parks (aka bus terminals) across the country.

Our President is a personality prone to hilarious performances. He has introduced another phony enterprise into the business of state with the planned ‘Modern Bus Terminals’ in the six geo-political zones of Nigeria. Please pay attention to the qualifier, ‘modern’ because what follows is pure superlative! When the government is deliberate in its dictions, using adjectives to qualify its head words, you should know that it has something up its sleeves.

The motor parks are evenly distributed this time around. The ‘dot on the map’ zone got its own fair share. There is no ojooro, no magomago, no wuruwuru! The principle of ‘Federal Character’ is at its best element. There will be one bus terminal in Kano. That will take care of the seven states in the North-West. One will be in Gombe for the six states of the North-East. The Confluence Town, Lokoja, Kogi State will have one for the entire people of the North-Central zone.

Down South, Abeokuta, Ogun State, will have one for all the children of Oduduwa in the South-West. The Ndigbo will all travel to the commercial city of Onitsha, Anambra State, to enjoy the proposed state-of-the-art bus terminal. The oil-rich Niger Delta is taken care of, also. Their motor park is going to be tucked in the belly of Ewu in Esan Central Local Government Area of Edo State.

Never mind the distance; never bother about the 9.3 hours travelling hours between Sokoto and Kano; a mere 537-kilometre distance. The government has the magic wand to bridge the gap and extend the dividends of the bus terminals to everybody. Fela Anikulapo Kuti called it “government magic”! This government works wonders! Ógbenután!

Now the main gist. Each motor park, the government said, would cost N23.6 billion. Please don’t shout! Yes, the bus terminals will be built with bricks and mortar. It will merely cost the country an arm, a leg and several pints of blood. That is not too much of a pain to inflict by a government that is far away from reality!

But the beauty of it all is that the bus terminals will be beautifully decorated and equipped with world-class facilities and equipment. When completed, Angels would no longer want to fly. Our Celestial brethren will travel our roads with us. That itself gives us peace of mind. Nothing can be safer than to be in the same bus with the Angels, the Malaikas and the principalities in high places! We are lucky folks, aren’t we?

No sarcasm is intended. Methinks that every Nigerian that will commence and terminate his or her journey at the bus terminals (please add modern), is guaranteed of his or her safety. How? Aso Rock Villa will be able to monitor every vehicle that leaves each of the bus terminals (or is it bus stop sef?). I put my shirt on it! It is a sure banker! A N23.6 billion bus terminal must have security gadgets that should be able to monitor our present, our progress and our future! If it is otherwise, then it is a waste of resources, and President Tinubu blocks wastages!

Nigeria is an ojúmó kan, àrà kan (one day, one stunt) country. We don’t run out of damfool ideas here. The only thing in short supply is a leadership with depth. A complacent followership equally promotes inept leadership. We are gradually gravitating towards the precipice of a failed nation. Many people believe we are already one!

President Tinubu may end up the luckiest president by the time he completes his tour of duty. He is one president who treats the country like his personal estate. And he gets away with it, all the time. Nobody questions him, nobody interrogates his policies. Nobody has the temerity to say: “Baba Seyi, you are not fair to us.”

In Aso Rock Villa, where he lives at our expense, Tinubu marks off the number of the strokes he has administered to our backs. Then, he takes his champagne. Or is it freshly tapped palm wine? He asks the boys to go back to procure more canes for future flogging. We are completely pummelled! How does he do that; how does he achieve that total appropriation of the people’s resilience? 

We simply swallow whatever pill the President forces down our throats. We agonise like the proverbial woman being pleasured by a man with a big phallus.  And nothing more. She merely waits in palpable trepidation for the next round of tortuous grinding.

Nigerians have been conditioned to be perpetually complacent by a government that trades in poverty and profits by inflicting pain!  We blech. We stretch. We look for any available pillow to rest our weary heads. Then we wait for the next round of dosage. Our ruiners of this epoch are not just mean, wicked and audacious; they are inorganic, pathologically cold-blooded!

That the Tinubu administration is heavily transactional is no longer ‘a topic for future symposium’ (apologies to Fela). That itself is not the real problem, not the real bad case, here. The brazen way the administration goes about its Mr-Giwa-is-a-trader activities is the most irritating. The citizenry appears completely battered such that not a whimper is heard from them anytime the government comes up with its nothing-go-happen policies.

By the approval given by the FEC last Wednesday, the six motor parks, colourfully presented to us as “Modern Bus Terminals’, will be built for the sum of N142,028,576,008.17. Nigeria’s FEC is the gathering of all ministers and any appointee of cabinet rank. Sa’idu Ahmed Alkali, the Minister of Transportation, told us FEC approved the project.

By simple arithmetic formula of division, the cost of each terminal is N23.6 billion! That will depend on the inflation rate between when the contract is awarded and when it is executed. If prices of goods and services go up the way they do daily in Nigeria, there will be room for contract variation. So, by the time the terminals are ready, the cost might have gone up.

When Alkali announced the ‘deal’, my mind raced to my secondary school days when we were taught Types of Legislative Power. Did our Government subject teachers misinform or miseducate us by saying that building a motor park is a function listed in the Residual Legislative List? Were they wrong to have said that construction, running and the maintenance of motor parks or ‘modern bus terminals’ are the responsibilities of the third tier of government, the local government? Do I simply say this “is confusing me?”

The minister, a former senator, while justifying this put-on, attributed “crimes, road accidents and illegal arms proliferation” to the lack of major bus terminals in the country. How can a man be phony and funny at the same time? How do we situate this type of reasoning: “because there are no bus terminals to address the interests of millions of Nigerian commuters, as a result, we have a lot of crime, road traffic accidents, and proliferation of arms and ammunition on our highways?”

What logic! In Alkali’s reasoning and Tinubu’s approval, once these bus terminals are built, all the bandits, kidnappers and other felons operating all over Nigeria will have no way to move their weapons? The Kano bus terminal designated for the North-West for instance, would ensure that bandits in Kaduna, Kebbi, Jigawa, Sokoto, Katsina and Zamfara are shut out of arms and ammunition supply? What exactly is lacking in this administration?

How would a government think that in 2025, a bus terminal built in Abeokuta, Ogun State capital, would solve the road transportation problems of the remaining states in the South-West? Couldn’t we have channelled the N142,028,576,008.17 to the East-West Road that has remained in a state of interminable construction?

How does one explain that of all the problems confronting us as a nation, the priority of this administration is the construction of “modern bus terminals” in the six geo-political zones of the country? How do we tell generations to come that at a time Nigeria was battling with insurgency and banditry in the North and kidnapping, farmers cum herders’ clash in the South, the Federal Government was busy constructing motor parks, a project that local government councils could handle? Why this lack of compunction by this government of promised but undelivered ‘hope’?

In China, there is a bridge that is 168.8 kilometres long. The Danyang-Kunshan Grand Bridge is rated as the world’s longest bridge, spanning 164 kilometres! Constructed between April 18, 2006, and November 15, 2010, the bridge cost the Chinese Government $8.6 billion US dollars. That, in our currency, is a whopping N13.175 trillion.

Back here in Nigeria, we have our darling 3rd Mainland Bridge built by the Alhaji Shehu Shagari and General Ibrahim Badamasi Babangida (IBB) administrations in two phases between 1980 and 1990. The span of the 3rd Mainland Bridge is 11.8 kilometres. And to repair the bridge, this administration said it would cost us N3.6 trillion! In mathematical terms, the cost of repairs on the 3rd Mainland Bridge is one-third the cost of the construction of Danyang-Kunshan Grand Bridge.

To know who we are and what the government thinks we are, we must understand that the Chinese Danyang-Kunshan Grand Bridge is 14 times longer than our 3rd Mainland Bridge! If Fela were to be here today, he would simply sing: arrangee na be that o. And he would be right!

That is not all. In the last two weeks again, the FEC also approved the sum of N712 billion to remodel the Murtala Muhammed International Airport (MMIA). In justifying this prodigious spending, we were told that by the time the facelifts were completed, Angels would want to fly to Nigeria because the airport would be as beautiful as the gold-paved streets of heaven!

Nobody is saying, by any stretch of argument, that the government should not fix decaying infrastructure. Our argument here is that the government should get its priorities right. The data gleaned from the Nigerian Civil Aviation Authority (NCAA) as of December 2023, gave a figure of over 5.9 million passengers at the MMIA in two years.

What percentage of Nigeria’s estimated population of over 200 million people is that? The simple implication is that there are far more Nigerians on the road than in the air. A government that is masses-sensitive will address critical segments that touch the lives of the highest population distribution. If more than 70 percent of Nigerians use road transportation, the focus should be on building more roads in addition to rehabilitating existing failed roads across the country.

In the last one week, Ekiti State has been in the news for the wrong reasons of the bad roads there. The videos of the terrible states of the roads are too graphic to ignore. The state is almost completely cut off from the rest of the country. And the situation is the same in all states of the Federation. There is no state in Nigeria without its own tales of woes when it comes to bad roads.

Worst hit is the Niger Delta where we get the resources that oil the engine of Nigeria. It is an eternal shame that the East-West Road has remained in perpetual state of construction. It is a national embarrassment that the terrible state of the Benin-Warri Expressway makes people spend six hours on a journey that was less than one hour before!

For Pete’s sake, the MMIA is not in a beauty pageant with any international airport. Yes, fix it, make it good but not with the humongous figures the government is throwing at us. That we are not hunters does not mean we cannot identify the spores of games on wet soil (àìi sode rí, kò ní ká má mo sa kò ko níhîn). If the government is looking for chop money for the boys, it should come out clean.

The defence by Tunde Moshood, Special Adviser on Media and Communications to Festus Keyamo, the Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, asking Nigerians to adopt a ‘more informed and constructive approach’ to the N712 billion MMIA project, is to say the least, very insensitive and insulting to our sensibilities. We cannot all be slaves to our stomachs; Moshood should be told to be bold enough to advise his boss and the government he represents that certain things can wait.  He and his boss are the ones to learn to gauge the mood of the people before they begin to call the dog monkey for us!

A Federal Government that is talking about building motor parks in a true Federal State needs elementary tutorials in Government and Devolution of Power. Minister Alkali got it completely wrong to think that lack of bus terminals is the reason why crimes like kidnapping and armed robbery happen on our highways.

The felons on the bad spots of the death traps we call highways don’t need any bus terminal or motor park to operate. They don’t have to register their vehicles and their content before they move to ‘sites’. We should be able to boast of someone with bare-bones penetration in this government. The jejune argument for the Federal Government ‘Modern Bus Terminals’ is annoying, very unnerving.

It is odiously nauseating that presumed men and women of class sat in that FEC to approve such a proposal. If the short among them is lacking in depth, the tall should show acuity (bí kékeré won bá gò, ó ye kí gíga won gbón). Someone should have shot down the Alkali’s proposal as lacking in sensitivity to the needs of the people. Someone should have reasoned that Nigerians cannot be going through the pain in the land and a FEC would be debating or approving inane proposals like the motor park project, no matter the deodorant sprayed on it!

How did they all sleep with their heads in one direction in that Council? How did the cabinet members come up with the conclusion that six motor parks in six different locations in our 36-state federation is the best the government could offer? And these are the ones leading Nigeria of 2025? Yes-men and women with illogical minds? Ghosh!

Can someone please tell President Tinubu to spare us this farce! Can those close to the President tell him that his boy, MC Oluomo, cannot be doing the monkey business of motor park management pan Nigeria as NURTW President,  while the Jagaban himself is running the same show at the centre, from Aso Rock? This ‘Modern Bus Terminals’ project is nothing but an agbero business. Mr. President, e kúrò nídìí ìdò, eré omodé ni (Leave the hide and seek game, it’s juvenile play)!

The views expressed by contributors are strictly personal and not of Law & Society Magazine.

Imo bans graduation ceremonies for nursery, kindergarten, JSS 3 students

The Imo State Government has placed an immediate ban on graduation ceremonies for kindergarten, nursery, and junior secondary school pupils.

Bernard Ikegwuoha, the Commissioner for Education, announced the policy in a memo addressed to parents, guardians, and stakeholders in the state’s education sector.

The measure, he said, is aimed at reducing financial burdens on parents and redirecting focus to the academic development of children.

He also directed school proprietors to stop the annual change of textbooks, describing the practice as financially draining and destabilising for families.

According to the commissioner, the new directive forms part of a wider policy designed to promote a more focused and efficient education system that benefits students, parents and society at large.

“The Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education in Imo State is committed to providing quality and functional education to all students. To achieve this goal, the Ministry has established guidelines on graduation ceremonies and textbook usage in schools,” the statement read.

On graduation ceremonies, Ikegwuoha emphasised that only Primary 6 pupils and senior secondary school students are permitted to hold graduation events.

“Henceforth, ceremonies and parties for kindergarten, nursery, and JSS3 students are hereby abolished,” he said.

Regarding textbooks, the commissioner explained that schools must adopt the approved list and use them for at least four years so that siblings can reuse them.

He warned proprietors, particularly in private and faith-based schools, against frequent changes, saying the practice imposes financial strain on parents and undermines educational stability.

“By adopting the approved textbooks and allowing them to be used for the specified period, schools can promote a more efficient and effective learning environment,” he added.

The ministry said it would monitor compliance closely and take action against any school found violating the policy.

Meanwhile, many residents of Imo State have welcomed the initiative on social media, describing it as a relief from what they called exploitative practices by school proprietors who used graduation parties to extort parents.

Photo News: Dr. Ogwu Onoja, SAN, lawyers at Bar & Bench publishers, others inducted as FRSC Special Marshals

Last Saturday in Abuja, Senior Advocate of Nigeria and proprietor of the proposed Lugard University, Abuja, along with his wife, Mrs. Rosemary Onoja, a chartered accountant, over 20 lawyers and staff members of his Bar & Bench Publishers, as well as other Nigerians, got inducted as Special Marshals of the Federal Road Safety Corps  (FRSC).

Dr.Ogwu James Onoja, SAN and Mrs Rosemary Onoja

The event organised by Unit 1 Special Marshal of FRSC’s RS.1 Sector Command, Wuse Zone 7, FCT, took place during the 2025 2nd quarter durbar/recognition/change of baton/sendoff ceremony.

Below are more photos of the event.

Flight Rage: Inner story of KWAM 1, Emmason’s pardon

  • The Consequences of No Consequence!
  • Comfort Emmason says, ‘I’ve forgiven everyone’

New details have emerged on why the Federal Government backtracked on its earlier decision to punish popular Fuji musician, Wasiu Ayinde, aka KWAM 1, and a passenger on the Akwa Ibom-owned airline, Ms. Comfort Emmason, for misconduct.

Findings by Saturday PUNCH showed that KWAM 1 was compelled to apologise as part of conditions for intervention from the ‘powers that be’, just as the government withdrew charges against Emmason after reviewing the roles of the airline in the saga and the threats of multiple suits.

Hasty trial

On August 10, Emmason was removed from a flight from Lagos to Uyo after allegedly refusing to turn off her phone as instructed by crew members.

The situation escalated when she became physically aggressive, struck a flight attendant, and had to be restrained and escorted off the aircraft at the Murtala Mohammed International Airport.

On account of that, Ibom Air imposed a lifetime ban on her from both local and international flights, citing its zero-tolerance policy toward violent or disruptive behaviour.

She was also arraigned and remanded in the Kirikiri Correctional Centre.

Wasiu Ayinde, on 5 August, caused a disruption at the Nnamdi Azikiwe International Airport, Abuja, when he attempted to board a ValueJet flight carrying a flask containing liquid beyond the permissible size.

When staff asked him to surrender it, he allegedly refused, poured its contents on the crew and security personnel, and then moved onto the tarmac to obstruct the aircraft from taxiing and delaying the flight’s safe operation.

The Nigeria Civil Aviation Authority petitioned the Inspector-General of Police, Kayode Egbetokun, to investigate the matter.

Ayinde was also placed on a six-month flight ban.

But Emmason’s prosecution for a criminal offence sparked outrage as a section of the public accused the government of bias, saying it failed to prosecute Ayinde, who allegedly committed a more grievous offence.

However, the Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, Festus Keyamo, SAN, announced on Wednesday that the government had directed the withdrawal of criminal complaints against Emmason and Ayinde.

Keyamo also said the government had told the NCAA to name Ayinde as an ambassador for airport security protocols.

The minister’s announcement was also greeted with mixed reactions, as some members of the public believe that the Federal Government pardoned Emmason in a bid to protect Ayinde, a well-known loyalist of President Bola Tinubu, from prosecution.

Saving airlines from suit

Insiders knowledgeable about the case told Saturday PUNCH that the government and the airline authorities needed to reach a compromise, de-escalate the matters, and save many of the individuals involved from prosecution and potential court cases.

According to a source, who is a top security officer at the Nnamdi Azikiwe International Airport, the airlines involved in the two cases were also not interested in pursuing their individual cases against Ayinde and Emmason having realised that the two passengers had “strong cases” against them if allowed to go to court.

He said, “The truth of the matter is that the aviation security, airline security, and the pilot, and all parties involved in Wasiu Ayinde’s case were at fault. The same thing with the Ibom Air case involving the lady who was stripped half-naked.

“I am aware that lawyers and stakeholders in the airlines and the aviation authorities reviewed the cases and opted for alternative conflict resolution to avoid lawsuits and counter-lawsuits. The Minister of Aviation was sincere in his statement when he said the decision was on compassionate grounds.”

Ayinde’s apology

Other insiders at the Ministry of Aviation told Saturday PUNCH that the reason for the reversal of what they called “hasty and harsh” decisions by both the government and the airlines was because preliminary investigations available to the government had shown that the airline was also culpable for the chaos at the airport in Emmason’s case.

“The soft landing or compromise is actually in favour of the airline in the case of Emmason. Everything was about protecting them from potential huge loss that would arise from any suit filed by the passenger,” said an insider, who spoke on condition of anonymity as she was not empowered to speak on the matter.

Another source, a top official at the ministry, told one of our correspondents that there were interventions from the ‘powers that be’ in Ayinde’s case, though the minister insisted on doing the right thing.

The source said, “The powers that be compelled KWAM 1 to apologise as a condition for intervening in the matter. They felt embarrassed about his attitude.

“After his apology, the industry was already speaking about Emmason, while still planning what to do about KWAM 1. The lady’s case became the talk of the town, especially after she was hastily remanded without hearing from her.

“The blowback from that action forced the hands of the government to find a general amicable solution to the matter.

“The resolution we all heard was a face-saving measure for both the government’s hasty and harsh decision on Emmason and also to find a soft landing for the musician, who is a friend to powerful people in government.”

Who filmed Emmason half-naked?

Many Nigerians were enraged after video clips of Emmason being dragged from the airplane half-naked went viral.

Ibom Air denied that any of its staff recorded or released the dehumanising clip to the public, as Keyamo slammed the release of the clip.

Independent review of the clips making the rounds on social media showed that only an airport official could have made the recording and released the graphic clips to the public.

For instance, a 28-second clip showed calls to “drag her out” as three men, joined by the Ibom Air hostess, identified as Juliana Edward, pulled an unwilling Emmason out.

The person behind the recording, a female, could be heard responding on a walkie-talkie that “there is a situation here, standby”.

Emmason’s clothes also appeared to have been pulled up by an official before her bosom was exposed.

Her lawyer, Adefunke Maria, alleged that the air hostess “wilfully ripped off” her blouse while security men manhandled her.

Also, a five-minute, 20-second clip revealed that only officials of Ibom Air, Federal Airport Authority of Nigeria, and security agents were around the scene of the incident.

Most of them wore reflective jackets.

For a second time, the person behind the video could be seen with her walkie-talkie, which was clearly visible in the first few seconds of the clip.

A member of the team could also be heard confirming that an official was already making a recording of the violent acts of the passenger, while urging the colleagues to be mindful of their action on camera.

Co-passenger shares experience

I’ve forgiven everyone, says Emmason

Emmason on Friday took to her Facebook page to share in detail how she was allegedly harassed and intimidated on the flight.

She said she had no intention of being unruly, adding that she was insulted by the air hostess.

She lamented that she was dragged like a criminal after the incident degenerated.

The Facebook post, made around 6 pm, read, “I boarded the flight peacefully like every other passenger, with no intention of disturbing anyone. I took my seat and waited for take-off.

“While we were still on the ground, the cabin crew started the normal safety checks, and that was when I was asked to switch off my phone.

“I politely explained that my phone had a faulty power button, and because of that I normally let the battery run down or use airplane mode instead. I also told the air hostess that if she could assist me, I would gladly hand over the phone for her to switch it off herself.”

Emmason said the first hostess who spoke to her was polite and understanding, adding that the second flight attendant spoke in a disrespectful tone.

The female passenger said, “She said, ‘I don’t have time for your excuses. Just switch it off.’ I calmly tried to explain again, but she cut me short and said, ‘If you don’t want trouble, you had better obey.’

“At that point, some passengers sitting close to me even intervened, and one of them helped me switch the phone off completely.

“Even after the phone was switched off, the same air hostess continued looking at me in a very aggressive way, almost as if she wanted a fight. I kept quiet because I didn’t want any trouble.”

Emmason noted that throughout the flight, she remained on her seat and did not disturb anyone.

She said, “I didn’t raise my voice, and I didn’t abuse or threaten any staff. Even the hostess who treated me harshly never came to apologise — she just kept watching me from afar.

“When we landed, everybody began to disembark. I waited for others to go first. As I was stepping out, that same hostess confronted me again and started saying things like: ‘You think you can threaten people here and go free. Wait, we will show you.’

“At that moment, I felt intimidated and embarrassed in front of other passengers. I asked her, ‘Madam, what exactly did I do to you?’ Instead of answering, she raised her hand as if she wanted to touch me again. I instinctively defended myself and told her not to harass me.

“Before I knew what was happening, they had already called security and labelled me as an ‘unruly passenger.’

“I begged them to at least watch the videos on the passengers’ phones so they would know the truth — but nobody listened. I was dragged off the aircraft like a criminal, still begging them to hear me out.

“At the airport police station, one of the managers from Ibom Air arrived and presented a completely different story, claiming that I assaulted their staff and threatened the safety of the flight. I immediately denied this and asked again for them to watch the videos, but my voice was ignored.

“Instead, I was moved straight to detention and eventually taken to Kirikiri, even though I kept insisting I was innocent.

“Everything I went through started from a faulty phone power button and a hostess who chose to abuse her authority instead of simply helping a passenger.

“I have forgiven everyone involved — but I felt it was important to finally share the truth of what happened, because a lot of people still don’t know my side.

“To everyone who stood up for me when I couldn’t speak, to everyone who prayed and fought for my freedom — thank you. God bless you all.”

‘No romance behind 500,000 job’

Meanwhile, the Special Adviser to the Delta State Governor on Media, Success Ossai, explained why he offered a N500,000 monthly salary job to Emmason.

In an Instagram post on Wednesday, Ossai announced that a monthly salary of N500,000 had been secured for the female passenger in the state.

The package, according to Ossai, also includes flight tickets, accommodation in a five-star hotel, a guided tour, and a ticket to the Delta Social Media Summit scheduled for August 28 in Asaba.

Ossai said the summit would enable her to interact with others, share her experience, and inspire people to avoid negative conduct.

Speaking in an interview with Saturday PUNCH, the governor’s aide clarified that the gesture was not from the state government but a personal decision to help Emmason reintegrate into society.

While dismissing speculations of having a romantic interest in her, he said, “I’m a married man and a faithful man. I can never get myself involved with such a thing. I am just offering harmless assistance to her.

“The gesture shown to the passenger wasn’t from the state government. It’s my personal gesture. She has shown remorse for what she did. Whatever has happened has happened. She went to Kirikiri prison and came back. It is time to support her as well.”

Reacting to criticisms that his offer could encourage unruly behaviour among air passengers, Ossai disagreed, citing global examples of rehabilitating offenders into advocates of good conduct.

Asked why he extended the offer despite Emmason not being from Delta State, Ossai said, “In Delta State, we don’t discriminate. We offer help to people, whether you are from Delta State or not. We are first Nigerians before anything else.”

He noted that his expectation was for Emmason to become disciplined, self-reliant, and a job creator.

Lawyer files N500bn suit

Meanwhile, a public interest lawyer, Ayodele Ademiluyi, has instituted a N500bn suit against the Federal Government, the Nigerian Civil Aviation Authority, and other parties at the Federal High Court in Lagos, accusing them of grossly violating the rule of law in the handling of the two aviation incidents.

Ademiluyi urged the court to use the matter as a landmark opportunity to affirm that no individual, regardless of prominence, is beyond legal accountability. On an Enugu Air flight to Lagos from Abuja this morning, August 16th, another mild drama played out briefly.

The Consequences of No Consequence! By Olawale Olaleye

On an Enugu Air flight to Lagos from Abuja this morning, August 16th, another mild drama played out briefly.

As the plane taxied, the pilot, a female captain, announced that there was a recalcitrant passenger who had declined switching off his phone as instructed, and that if the fellow insisted, she might be left with no option than to make a U-turn. At this point, she had stopped on the runway.

Hearing this warning, other passengers took it upon themselves and started shouting at this potentially disruptive passenger. Eventually, he turned off his phone, and the journey to Lagos continued.

But here is why this piece became compelling and timely. While the purser, a calm and well-mannnered lady, was appealing to him to turn off his phone and he refused, hear what he said to her: “Wetin happen for Ibom Air go happen for here now now.”

That’s the result of having a poor reward and sanction system with no consequences. If those who had tried this nonsense had faced the penalties for their action and not the shameful “slap on the wrist” punishment meted out to them, another irreverent passenger would not open his mouth and say, “Wetin happen for Ibom Air go happen for here now now.”

No serious nation tramples on its own laws or chooses when to enforce it or not and against whom. The two recent breaches in air safety protocols and their handling have shown how unserious we are as a people and also why our leadership will continue to create strong people as against strong institutions. It is a conscious decision. It has never been an accident.

With the disastrous handling of the K1 and the K2 matters, even though no attention was given to the incident tagged K3, a template has been created already and it will haunt the Aviation Sector for a long time to come. The shame is not just for the leadership. The people, too, share a large chunk of it as intentional enablers of bad behaviours.

Fans and supporters of the Fuji king are now buying similar gold flasks as a form of solidarity with him, displaying it with arrogance of “na we dey power.” Also, practically every money-miss-road, including government officials, had offered “Auntie Komfo” one form of comfort or the other, obviously because…

But such people will never offer similar encouragement to outstanding students in any field or institution. We celebrate silly things and reward bad behaviours at the expense of more edifying tangibles and intangibles. Indeed, Nigeria and her people are a case study in human civilisation.


UNICEF drums up support for enhanced and effective breastfeeding in Nigeria

The United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) has urged governments, families, employers, media, and other stakeholders to intensify efforts toward promoting effective breastfeeding practices across Nigeria.

Mr. Muhammad Okorie, UNICEF’s Social Policy Manager in Lagos, made the call in an interview with the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) on Sunday.

He noted that breastfeeding requires a strong support system and collective commitment, stressing that women should be encouraged to exclusively breastfeed their babies for the first six months of life and continue up to two years and beyond.

Okorie urged governments to implement policies that foster a breastfeeding-friendly culture, including enforcing regulations on advertisements of infant formula and providing flexible working conditions for nursing mothers.

Creating a conducive working environment has become imperative in the face of multiple challenges faced by working mothers,” he said, while advocating for six months of paid maternity leave to be made universal across both public and private sectors.

The UNICEF official also emphasised the central role of families in supporting breastfeeding mothers, saying strong family backing helps to overcome stigma, misinformation, and cultural barriers.

“To improve breastfeeding practice, families must adopt love, compassion, and understanding, fostering a positive environment for mothers,” he said.

He encouraged parents to adopt the 1:6:24 approach — initiating breastfeeding within one hour after birth, exclusively breastfeeding for the first six months, and continuing alongside complementary feeding for 24 months.

Okorie highlighted the numerous benefits of breastfeeding, including improved infant nutrition, reduced child mortality, protection against diseases, and stronger bonds between mother and child.

He also underscored the role of the media in promoting accurate information on breastfeeding and countering misconceptions.

“Breastfeeding promotes healthy growth and development, reduces infant mortality, and contributes to the overall well-being of children,” he said.

Frustrated man cuts off penis after wife shunned reconciliation

50-year-old Modu Isa must have been deeply frustrated when his wife refused to return home after a marital dispute.

Last Saturday, security analyst and counter-insurgency expert, Zagazola Makama, disclosed via his X handle that tragedy struck in Bama, Borno State, when Mallam Isa, reportedly, attempted to take his own life by stabbing himself in the stomach and cutting off his genitals following a dispute with his now estranged wife.

According to residents of Hausari Ward, where the incident occured, Isa took the drastic step after Bayanxe Modu allegedly refused to return to their marriage.

“He said if his wife could not have him, then no one should,” a neighbour told reporters.

Isa was rushed to the General Hospital, Bama, where medical personnel performed an emergency operation to save his life and reattach his severed organ.

The bizarre episode has sparked mixed reactions in the community, with some residents expressing sympathy while others described the act as shocking and incomprehensible.

Meanwhile, security sources revealed that the case has been transferred to the Criminal Investigation Department in Maiduguri for further inquiry.

When contacted, the Police Public Relations Officer in Borno State, ASP Nahum Daso, said he was aware of the incident but declined further comment, noting that investigations were ongoing.

AFBA 2025: Have you registered? Ghana is waiting for you!

The 2025 Annual conference of the African Bar Association (AFBA) is scheduled to be held from Sunday, 19th October to Thursday, 23rd October 2025 in Accra, Ghana.

📌Have you registered? 📌

Below is a detailed schedule of Conference Registration Fees-

From August 1st – September 30th

  1. Members of AFBA – $600
  2. ⁠Non-Members- $800

From October 1st and at the Conference Venue

  1. Members of AFBA- $700
    Non-Members- $900

For Judges, Magistrates, and Academics
FLAT RATE- $500

For Young Lawyers [7 years post enrollment and below] FLAT RATE

  1. Members of AFBA- $300
    Non-Members- $400

Guests – [NON-LAWYERS ONLY]- $400

Registration can be made using the online platform only at http://www.afribar.org

Also, a notice signed by Faith Onyekperem Esq. ACArb, the secretariat administrator of AFBA, disclosed that membership renewal for the year 2025 is ongoing, and new members are welcome.

To register as a new member and or to renew your AFBA membership, kindly make payment using the online platform at www.afribar.org

📌PLEASE NOTE- There shall be no Manual NAIRA Payment at the Bank
Members are kindly requested to log in to use the online platform for all payment categories.

FEES

  1. New Membership for over 7 years. Post Call $200 and Annual Renewal- $100
  2. ⁠Young Lawyers 0- 7 years. Post call $100 and Annual Renewal- $50
  3. ⁠Student membership is $50, and Annual Renewal $25
  4. ⁠Non-Africans $500 and Annual Renewal- $250
  5. ⁠Bar Associations, Law Societies, and Corporate Members- $1000 Annual Renewal- $1000

For further inquiries, contact:

WhatsApp number-
+2348067820024
+2347030793742
+2348033918753
+2348034518185

OR by email to [email protected], [email protected]


[Again] “You Performed Excellently”, NJC to applaud National Industrial Court’s Justice Ogbuanya

The National Judicial Council’s (NJC) Judges’ Performance Evaluation Committee under the Chairmanship of HRH, Hon. Justice Bage Muhammad 1, JSC (rtd.), has once again applauded Hon. Justice Nelson Ogbuanya of the National Industrial Court of Nigeria for Excellent Performance for the  1st and 2nd Quarters 2024 Assessment of Return of Cases by Judges of Superior Courts of Record in Nigeria.

One of the core objectives of the Performance Evaluation Committee is to provide adequate mechanisms to enhance the performance of Judicial Officers through continuous monitoring, evaluation, accountability, and learning to improve effective and efficient productivity in our Courts.

In a two separate Letters of  Commendation dated 7th July 2025 addressed to Hon. Justice N.C.S Ogbuanya, through the Office of the President of the Industrial Court, and signed by Secretary to the NJC Committee on Performance Evaluation, Abdullahi Tafarki, Esq., on behalf of the  Chairman of the Committee, it was noted with admiration that Justice Ogbuanya performed excellently well by delivering 25 Judgments and 27 Judgments during the 1st and 2nd Quarters 2024, respectively.

According to the double commendation letters, the Committee urged His Lordship to keep up the stride. 

It would be recalled that the Committee had earlier in November 2023 commended Justice Ogbuanya for Excellent Performance by delivering 28 Judgments in the 2nd Quarter of the 2022 year of Assessment of Return of Cases by Judges of Superior Courts of Record in Nigeria.  

As one of our shining stars, the National Industrial Court celebrates Justice Ogbuanya for achieving this milestone of consistent excellent performance, which is not only a reflection of hard work but also in recognition of Justice Ogbuanya’s exceptional judicial sacrifice to justice development.

Source NICN

APC and lessons from Oyo by-election

By Lasisi Olagunju

The Cambridge English dictionary defines ‘carcass’ as “the body of a dead animal, especially a large one.” The People’s Democratic Party (PDP) was recently described as “a carcass” by one of its former governors, Mr Ayodele Fayose. Yet, that carcass defeated the reigning lion, the APC, in a decisive election in Oyo State at the weekend. PDP was dead; PDP is not dead. If I were the APC presidency, I would accept this reality as a divine warning. I would go back to work; I would talk and scheme less, I would start working truly for the people’s welfare. I would know that only this will kill the ‘dead’ enemy.

An APC leader told me that the Oyo election result was “the effect of bizarre developments in the APC.” He said the APC candidate “scored 6 (six) votes in his polling unit.” Oyo State APC truly has a huge reward problem. It has the liability of a Lagos-centric Abuja, unfair in appointments in Oyo, imperial in disposition. Does this solely explain the loss? It does not. Listen. I work and live in Ibadan and I know that the state governor, Seyi Makinde, has a firm grip on the politics of the state. His stellar performance as governor and his humility before the palace and the people have made it very easy for everyone to be his friend. It will take more than ‘federal might’ to defeat such a person now and in the future. Indeed, the by-election was a referendum on his six-year tenure as governor. It was also a pointer to how well the APC and its federal government have sold themselves to the people of Oyo State.

Defence Minister, Alhaji Muhammad Badaru Abubakar, is the immediate past governor of Jigawa State. His image handlers spent the night of Saturday and the whole of Sunday fighting off the news that he lost his Jigawa State polling unit to the PDP. Because bad news is good news, the story of the minister’s loss was quite popular on the internet. Then a report surfaced on Sunday that “Badaru did not vote at PU 001. His accredited polling station is PU 002. There, the APC secured 188 votes while the PDP scored 164 votes.”

The unit which the minister is disowning is Babura Kofar Arewa Primary School PU 001, very next to the one he claimed, and both situated in the same primary school compound. At that Unit 001, while APC polled 112 votes, PDP won with 308. Now, do the arithmetic. The minister did not vote in that unit, but his polling unit shares the same location with this unit where his party lost with a margin of almost 200 votes. Can we just add the two units’ votes together and ask the powerful minister to say something? Did his party win the election in that location? If I were the minister, I would keep quiet and nurse the wounds inflicted by a mere carcass.

The ruling party must be very unhappy at the pushback it got across the country on Saturday. The APC wants to go into the 2027 elections without opposition. And it is working really hard to achieve that. Poisoned carrots in the air; State of Emergency and defections down there; arrest and detentions here and there. Who will warn ‘them’ that what they desire is lethal? Where there is no opposition, there is no check upon corruption; the government itself becomes the opposition to good governance, and ultimately its own death. Find out why there are ample provisions for His Majesty’s Government and His Majesty’s Loyal Opposition in England. There was a reason why democratic Canada, in 1905, provided a good salary for the leader of the opposition. Parliament voted that year to give the incumbent an additional salary allowance, “equal to that provided to Cabinet Ministers.”

C. P. Bhambhri in 1957 wrote ‘The Role of the Opposition in the House of the People (1952-56)’. In that seminal piece, he warns that: “In a community where no opposition parties are permitted, the alternative government is one of courtiers, policemen, soldiers and gangsters and it is only by violent methods that the government may be ousted.” It is the Indian’s argument that “an effective opposition renders a government a going concern. It prevents the formation of monopolies in politics. It ensures a neutral and non-political civil service and armed forces.”

Flood should stop thinking it will sweep away the river. What we saw in Saturday’s by-elections was a reassurance that despite everything, the opposition is alive in Nigeria, and the people and their democracy are safe. But it is not enough to be alive; it will be enough only if and when the opposition is not a living dead. A vibrant opposition is needed against a creepy dictatorship slithering into the walls of our democracy. Listen again to Bhambhri: “To find out whether a people is free it is necessary only to ask if there is an opposition and if there is, to ask where it is. The existence of a strong opposition is the greatest guarantee that there shall be no tyranny of the ruling party.”

So, the dead can come back, fight and win a war? There is a story in the October 1856 edition of the Church Missionary Society (CMS)’s ‘Quarterly Token For Juvenile Subscribers’. The story has this convoluted headline: ‘The dead, alive—The lost, found: Dasalu’s Odyssey.’ It is a story of death and of not dying. It reads: “In the Yoruba country, which you know is in West Africa, there was a town called Igbore. The Apena, or judge of the town, was named Deri. One of his sons, born about 1810, was generally called Dasalu, but sometimes Ogan. By and by, Igbore was destroyed by slave wars; but Deri and his family escaped to Iro. Afterwards they went to Ijana, where Deri died. Dasalu’s mother, Lutumbi, then took him to Ilaro, and finally to Abeokuta. Many Igbore people had settled there. That part of Abbeokuta in which they live is called Igbore. The boy grew up a bold, active young fellow, and the head of a party who used to roam about the country, seizing all the people they could, and selling them for slaves.” He later converted to Christianity and dropped his wild ways.

During the Dahomian invasion of Abeokuta on March 2, 1851, Dasalu was at the war front, defending his land. After the war, he was discovered to be among the missing. His elder brother, Lujobi, on the fifth day, claimed that he had found a headless corpse in a bush. He then proceeded to seize “the poor fellow’s property, to the amount of fifty pounds, as the headless corpse was claimed to be his.” However, it was later discovered that Dasalu had been captured, not killed, and was taken as a prisoner toward the coast. “Great was the stir the news made in Abeokuta. Well it might! Had not his dead body been found? So, everybody thought at the time. Everybody? Did Lujobi? Or did he knowingly pass off some other dead body (it was headless, remember) for Dasalu’s? Lujobi’s cruel conduct afterwards seems to condemn him.”

From his place of captivity, undead Dasalu managed to send a coded letter (àrokò) to his wife: a stone, a piece of charcoal, a pepper-pod, and a grain of parched maize, or Indian corn, all tied up in a rag.” What did this mean? “It meant that he was quite well, and as hard or strong as a stone. The prospect before him was, however, very dark, like charcoal. This has made him hot as pepper, and his body had dried like parched maize. While as for his cloth, it was a mere rag.” All attempts to ransom the man failed because he was known by his other name, Ogan. Years later, freed Yoruba returnees from Cuba brought news that Dasalu was alive there, writing as “Dasalu, the lost one.” He had been shipped as a slave but ended up in Havana after his vessel was seized. The British Consul eventually found him, and he was taken to England, where his photograph was made. So, Dasalu, once thought dead in the Dahomian war, was actually captured and enslaved, later found in Cuba, and eventually freed to return to his wife, Martha, in Abeokuta. His case is a dramatic story of loss, faith, betrayal, survival, and redemption.

The grim content of Dasalu’s aroko to his wife aptly represents the state of things with the PDP today. Like Dasalu, the carcass of the PDP rose from the cemetery to defeat the ‘Dahomians’ on Saturday in Ibadan. The Ibadan North Federal Constituency by-election saw a “dead” party blindsiding the all-powerful APC with 18,404 votes; the Abuja party struggled and netted 8,312. Now, do the maths: the difference is 10,092 votes. When a contest records such a margin of win, the Englishman would say it was a shellac. I would have borrowed from the Germans the word ‘blitzkrieg’ (lightning war) but that would have been grossly inappropriate to describe the Oyo State operation. It was not ‘surprise’ that overwhelmed the defeated on Saturday. No. Ogun Àwítélè means a war foretold; the defeated knew they would fall.

Check how the newspapers reported the result of Saturday’s electoral contests across the country; read the headlines: ‘PDP clears all 12 wards In Ibadan North by-election as APC candidate loses PU’;

‘Violence, vote-buying mar by-elections in Ogun, Kaduna, Kano;’ ‘Kano by-election marred by electoral malpractice, APC alleges’. Indian scholar, Railul Ramagundam, in January 2005, did a paper on the relationship between newspaper headlines and how a society is run. He entitled the piece: ‘The ‘State’ Revealed in Newspaper Headlines.’ The man says: “From a newspaper headline one can draw not just news and views about a society, but also ascertain the nature of the society and the state itself.” Those headlines are proof that Nigeria is very far from what the enemy designed for it: a one-party dictatorship.

Ramagundam wrote about India, but because scholarship is universal, we feel the validity of his thesis here, daily. Take this headline from last week: ‘After spending N21bn, FG budgets 180x more for Third Mainland Bridge repairs’. Someone in government would read this and wonder who the ‘subversive’ sub-editor was that cast that headline for Business Day newspaper. To announce the latest trillion naira contract binge of the Federal Government is to tell us that because opposition has collapsed in the parliament, money has become rainwater here. Almost all federal roads in the South -West are ‘dead’, less than two trillion naira will fix all of them. But works minister, David Umahi, said recently that he was begging the president for funds to fix the collapsed South-West roads; yet our president casually and calmly approved N3.8 trillion for a bridge repair in Lagos. And he will campaign for 2027 votes outside Lagos.

Each of the parties in Saturday’s by-elections across Nigeria must have learnt some lessons in how not to take the people for granted. For parties that are rent by the dog-eat-dog posture of politics, I recommend the Bible’s Mark 3:24-25: “And if a kingdom be divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand. And if a house be divided against itself, that house cannot stand.”

Folklorist Solomon T. Plaatje, in ‘English in Africa’ (September 1976) has this story for parties of the avaricious: Once upon a time a Bechuana village was attacked by an army, which chased the people from their homes. There remained among the ruins a cripple and a blind man. These two invalids agreed that the blind man should carry the cripple, that they should flee and follow the people. While they were passing through the country, the blind man carrying the cripple, the one who could see, saw some vultures hovering. So he told the one who had the use of his legs about it, and they went towards the place (where the vultures were hovering). There they found some vultures assembled round the carcass of a wild animal.

When they had driven away the vultures, a dispute arose between them (over the meat). The cripple said: “It was my eyes that found this anima”; the blind man said: “It was my feet that found it.” When their dispute became more heated, and they would not give in to one another, the cripple crawled away from the blind man. Then the blind man, being unable to see neither his companion nor the animal, called out: “My friend, it is evident that you are our eyes. Why should you lose your temper? I know that the animal was found by you.” The cripple heard his partner and came back and led the blind man to the animal, their food.

Our politicians will never step back as the blind man did. They quarrel over spoils, over positions, and over privileges, and won’t mind losing everything to birds of carrion.

The Bechuana tale speaks to the folly of selfishness and the wisdom of cooperation. It reflects directly on the greed of the avaricious in our politics. We wait to see which politician or party learns from this as we jog towards 2027, the year of the apocalypse. The cripple and blind man story teaches all scammers in power that collective survival depends on honest partnership; that those with vision need those with mobility, and vice versa. In 2015 and 2023, the wily among politicians forged alliances to take power; they succeeded in their mission; but the king and his men scammed many allies; they rewarded a few. They consolidated and moved further, scamming the people. Today, they elevate political 419 to state policy. With exclusive claims, they own a free meal they didn’t prepare. But do they know that their conduct invites vultures to come over, inherit and eat what should have sustained everyone?

Those who lost Saturday’s by-elections will lose the 2027 general elections unless they stop taking the people to be Shakespeare’s “blocks, stones… worse than senseless things.” The people may be hungry and powerless, but they are not stupid. They are waiting and watching. It is a cliché to say they will laugh last. Niyi Osundare says it better in ‘The Eye of the Earth’: the people always outlast the palace.

The views expressed by contributors are strictly personal and not of Law & Society Magazine.

TIPS